An interactive guide to Throughput Accounting
Why decisions that look good on a cost report can lose money, and three numbers that give better answers. Move the sliders and test a few decisions yourself.
Ask a cost accountant whether to accept a low-price order, buy a faster machine or outsource a part, and you’ll get an answer based on product cost: material plus labour plus a share of overhead. Those answers are often wrong, sometimes badly, because most of that “cost” doesn’t change with the decision.
Throughput Accounting, developed by Dr. Eliyahu M. Goldratt, replaces product cost with three numbers that describe the whole business.
1. Three numbers instead of product cost
- Throughput (T): the rate at which the business makes money through sales. Sales minus truly variable costs, usually raw material.
- Investment (I): money tied up in things the business owns to make money: stock, machines, buildings.
- Operating expense (OE): money spent to turn investment into throughput: wages, rent, power.
They connect to the bottom line in two lines: net profit = T − OE, and return on investment = (T − OE) ÷ I.
Move the sliders and watch profit and return change:
Notice the difference between the levers. OE and I can only fall so far before you cut into what the business needs. Throughput has no ceiling. That’s why TOC puts them in the order T first, then I, then OE: the opposite of most cost-cutting programmes.
2. Ask three questions about every decision
Instead of “what does it cost per unit?”, ask:
- How will it change T?
- How will it change I?
- How will it change OE?
A decision is good if it raises T, or lowers I or OE, without hurting the others more. Try a few:
A new machine would make a non-constraint 30% faster. The vendor shows a two-year payback from labour savings. What is the change in throughput?
- Zero, because the plant can’t sell more until the constraint can do more
- About 30%, because that part of the plant will now work 30% faster
- Equal to the labour savings that the vendor has shown in the proposal
Output is set by the constraint, so a faster non-constraint sells nothing extra. And the “labour savings” are real only if people leave the payroll. If nobody does, OE goes up (maintenance, power) while T stays flat.
3. When capacity is short, rank by the constraint
When the constraint is fully loaded, the question isn’t which product has the highest margin, but which earns the most throughput per minute of the constraint. A product with a lower margin can be far more profitable if it uses little constraint time.
Goldratt’s well-known P&Q example shows a plant that follows its cost report, pushes the “most profitable” product, and loses money doing it. The Mirage game below lets you run that plant both ways.
4. Decisions it changes
| Decision | Cost-world answer | Throughput answer |
|---|---|---|
| Low-price order, spare capacity | “Below cost: reject” | Accept if price beats material cost and it doesn’t steal constraint time |
| Faster machine at a non-constraint | “Labour savings: approve” | No extra T; usually reject |
| Outsource a part that uses the constraint | “Vendor price above our cost: keep it in-house” | Buying it frees constraint time for sales; often very profitable |
| Cut stock | “Profit falls” (absorbed overhead) | I falls, cash is freed, ROI rises |
Throughput Accounting doesn’t replace financial reporting. It replaces the use of allocated cost for decisions, which is where most of the damage is done.