Supply Chain · Operations

Tier-1 suppliers: caught between an unstable plan and unreliable sub-vendors

Mohit Saini · 28 Apr 2020 · 4 min read

Tier-1 suppliers: caught between an unstable plan and unreliable sub-vendors

Ask most tier-1 automotive suppliers about their delivery performance, and they will tell you they supply over 90% of what the vehicle maker asks for in a month. Ask the vehicle makers, and they will tell you their suppliers are unreliable and need constant follow-up.

Both are telling the truth. The gap between those two statements explains much of the stress in the auto supply chain.

The month that never goes to plan

Here is how a typical month unfolds:

  1. Around month start, the supplier receives a monthly plan with weekly schedules. It plans raw materials, parts and production batches, and passes the plan to its own (tier-2) suppliers.
  2. Within the first week, the vehicle maker changes the schedule: some items are needed earlier.
  3. The supplier expedites, replans and reschedules its sub-vendors. Some sub-vendors can’t cope and miss deliveries.
  4. The vehicle maker, unable to build vehicles without every part but unwilling to leave its line idle, changes the plan again.
  5. Meanwhile, the vehicle maker’s sales team finds that the models built don’t match what dealers want (forecasts are never accurate), and asks for still more changes.

And so the cycle repeats. Monthly delivery looks fine. Day-to-day delivery against the latest schedule doesn’t.

Stuck in the middle

Vehicle makers demand reliability, with reason: a missing part means stock-outs of some models, surpluses of others, lost line capacity and constant expediting. Unreliable suppliers lose business, and they lose the standing to ask for price increases.

Suppliers keep asking for a stable plan. Vehicle makers can’t give one. So suppliers protect themselves with large stocks of raw material and finished goods. But margins are thin, and working capital is limited. Worse, with plans changing constantly, the stock ends up mismatched: weeks of some parts, none of others. Suppliers carry heavy inventory and still firefight every day.

When a downturn arrives, demand drops suddenly, and the age of that inventory doubles or triples overnight. Many suppliers take heavy losses.

Why copying Toyota doesn’t help yet

Many vehicle makers have adopted versions of the Toyota Production System: a shift or two of parts at the line, ordered the same day or the day before. Without a stable plan, this pushes the chaos onto suppliers.

Some suppliers have copied the visible parts of Lean too: tiny raw material stocks, restricted storage space, daily deliveries expected from sub-vendors. With schedules changing daily and sub-vendors unable to respond that fast, it is nearly impossible to get every part on time.

Just-in-time works when two conditions hold: a stable plan from the customer, and suppliers equipped to respond. In most auto supply chains, neither holds yet.

The ideal fix lies with the vehicle maker

The real cure is for vehicle makers to replenish dealers according to actual daily sales, from a central stock of finished vehicles. The central stock pools variations from dealers across the country, so the plant’s load becomes much steadier. Sudden spikes are absorbed by the finished-vehicle buffer instead of being passed upstream. Suppliers would then see a fairly stable, uniform demand.

But that change is outside a tier-1 supplier’s control, and waiting for it won’t help.

What a tier-1 supplier can do now

The supplier can build a system that delivers reliably despite an unstable plan:

1. Supply from a finished-goods buffer. Hold a stock buffer for each part and meet the vehicle maker’s daily requirements from it. Production’s job becomes refilling the buffer, not chasing the latest schedule. This is the critical change.

2. Size the buffer to the reaction time. If all components are available, assembling most tier-1 products takes one to three days. A finished-goods buffer of roughly ten to twelve days can absorb any reasonable daily demand.

3. Prioritise by buffer colour. Divide each part’s target into three zones (red, yellow, green). When the day’s load exceeds capacity (absenteeism, breakdowns), produce red items first, then yellow.

Take one part. The vehicle maker uses about 400 a day on average, but on a bad day, when it rejigs its model mix, it can call for 700. The supplier can make the part within three days once material is in. A target of about 4,500 pieces, roughly eleven days of average use, absorbs even a run of heavy days. Green is above 3,000, yellow between 1,500 and 3,000, red below 1,500. On an ordinary morning the stock sits in green and the part waits its turn. After three heavy days it drops into yellow and moves up the queue. If it ever touches red, it is made first, ahead of everything else.

4. Do the same with tier-2 suppliers. Share daily buffer status with sub-vendors so they produce reds first. Persuade them to keep their own finished-goods buffers. Then the tier-1 supplier’s raw material stock only needs to cover transport time: a few days for local vendors, perhaps ten for distant ones. Sub-vendors gain too: steadier demand, clear priorities, and capacity no longer wasted on parts not needed yet.

5. Adjust buffers dynamically. If a part keeps falling into red without supply problems, demand has risen: raise its target by a third. Reduce more cautiously, over a longer period. In a downturn, the signal comes early, so stock comes down before it becomes a burden.

Suppliers who work this way typically reach very high daily delivery reliability, increase output and reduce inventory, and firefighting nearly disappears. Vehicle makers tend to reward such suppliers with more business, because reliable daily supply is worth far more than a slightly cheaper but unreliable source.

A supplier can’t stabilise its customer’s plan. It can stop being destabilised by it.

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion