Sales · Supply Chain

Trade schemes: are you paying to move stock, not to sell it?

Mohit Saini · 4 Oct 2020 · 4 min read

Trade schemes: are you paying to move stock, not to sell it?

Consumer goods and durables companies spend a large share of their marketing budgets not on consumers, but on the trade: distributors, wholesalers and retailers. Cash discounts, bonus packs, gold coins, appliances, foreign trips for the top performers. Most of these schemes are tied to buying a certain volume within a certain period.

In some categories, these trade schemes take a fifth of the promotion budget. In others, more than half. And yet, in many years, sales volume grows much more slowly than this spending.

So it is worth asking: what are these schemes really buying?

The two beliefs behind trade schemes

Trade schemes rest on two beliefs:

  1. The trade’s main need is a higher margin. Give the retailer more margin, and he will push your brand to customers.
  2. Stuffed shelves force selling. Once the retailer’s money is locked in your stock, he has to sell it, and he won’t have money left for competitors.

To test these beliefs, we need to understand what a trader actually wants.

What a trader really wants

A trader invests money in stock, sells it, and uses the cash to buy the next lot. What he makes in a year depends not just on his margin, but on how many times he turns his money. In other words, his return on investment:

ROI = (gross margin − operating expenses) ÷ (money in stock + net credit given to the market)

Let us take a simple example of a trader (figures in ₹ million per year):

Today Margin up 10% Stock cut by half
Gross margin 0.60 0.66 0.60
Operating expenses 0.25 0.25 0.25
Money in stock 1.2 1.2 0.6
Net market credit 0.8 0.8 0.8
ROI 17.5% 20.5% 25%

Halving the stock, without losing sales, does far more for the trader than a 10% increase in margin.

Which is more realistic? A 10% higher margin is expensive for any brand. Halving the trader’s stock sounds impossible, until we look at why he holds so much.

Why traders hold so much stock

In most categories, traders hold one to three months of stock, and much more in fashion, books or spare parts. Yet most brands have a stocking point within a few days’ travel of almost every trader. If those stocking points always had the full range available, a trader would need perhaps two to three weeks of stock to stay available.

He holds more because supplies are unreliable and because he is pushed to buy in large lots, often through the very schemes we are discussing. Over the years, traders have given up on reducing their stock, and so they negotiate on the only thing they can: margin.

Does margin make retailers push a brand?

Here is a simple test anyone can try. Walk into a few neighbourhood shops (not self-service stores) and ask for a toothpaste, a bulb or a packet of biscuits, saying you have no preference: “Give me whichever you think is best.” Note which brand you are handed.

In most cases, you will be given the leading brand, even when the shop stocks a lesser-known brand with a better margin.

Why? Because a shopkeeper cares more about the customer coming back to his shop than about which brand he sells. Recommending a well-known brand is safe. Recommending an unknown one is a risk to his reputation. Studies of retailer behaviour point the same way: retailers tend to favour established brands because they strengthen the store’s image with customers.

If retailers really steered customers towards higher-margin brands, their shelves wouldn’t be full of slow-moving stock bought under old schemes.

So what do schemes actually do?

Schemes rarely create demand. Mostly, they move excess stock from the company to the next link in the chain: stock that was made because of forecast errors and needs a home before month end. They solve a supply chain problem with marketing money.

That is also why simply withdrawing schemes is risky: the stock they used to move would pile up. To remove schemes safely, the supply chain must change too:

  • produce and distribute according to actual consumption, so there is no excess to push;
  • keep stocking points always available, so traders can hold less and turn their money faster.

Spend where the decision is made

If retailers don’t decide what consumers buy, who does? Spend the promotion budget there:

  • On the end customer, to create genuine demand.
  • On the real influencer. In auto parts, the mechanic often decides which brand of filter or brake pad goes into the vehicle; in paints, the painter or contractor; in building materials, the mason. A long-term loyalty programme for these influencers, instead of short schemes that create peaks and troughs, builds steady demand.
  • On the shop floor: displays and demonstrations that help customers understand the product.

Trade schemes pay the channel to hold your stock. Pull replenishment gives the channel what it really wants: a better return on its money.

When companies push stock and traders negotiate margins, both lose: the brand spends on schemes that don’t create demand, and the trader’s capital sits in the wrong stock. Replace the push with pull, and the conversation changes from margin to returns.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion