An interactive guide to the conflict cloud
Most stubborn problems are a tug-of-war between two good intentions. The conflict cloud draws it in five boxes, shows the assumptions underneath, and points to a way out without compromise.
Some problems keep coming back however many times they’re “solved”. A discount war in sales. Batch size in production. Whether to start a project now or later. Each side has good reasons, the argument goes round in circles, and the usual outcome is a compromise nobody likes.
The conflict cloud (also called the evaporating cloud) is one of the Thinking Process tools developed by Dr. Eliyahu M. Goldratt. It turns an argument about who is right into a search for which assumption is wrong.
The five boxes
Every cloud has the same shape:
- A, the objective both sides share.
- B and C, two needs. Both are required to reach A.
- D and D′, two actions that seem to follow from B and from C, and that can’t both be done.
Read it aloud from left to right: in order to A, we must B; in order to B, we must D. And on the other side: in order to A, we must C; in order to C, we must D′. But D and D′ conflict.
Step through a cloud from sales:
Where the way out hides
The arrows matter more than the boxes. Under each arrow sit assumptions: the reasons we believe that link must hold. Most are true. One or two usually aren’t, or are only true sometimes.
In the example, “the buyer chooses mainly on price” sounds obvious. But many buyers complain about price while what really costs them money is late delivery. If that assumption is false, there’s an option that serves both needs: hold the price and win the order on reliability.
That new option is an injection. It doesn’t split the difference; it removes the reason for the conflict.
Why look for an injection instead of agreeing on a fair compromise, such as half the discount?
- A compromise is never acceptable, under any circumstances at all
- A compromise satisfies neither need fully, so the conflict returns next time
- Injections are always cheaper and quicker to put in place than compromises
Half a discount still erodes the margin and may still lose the order. Both needs stay partly unmet, so the same argument comes back next month. An injection that breaks a false assumption can satisfy both needs at once.
Build your own in four steps
- Start from the conflict: write the two actions people argue about, D and D′.
- Ask why: for each action, what need does it serve? Those are B and C.
- Find the shared objective: what do both needs serve? That is A.
- Surface assumptions under every arrow, then challenge each one: is it really so? Always?
Clouds work for small daily dilemmas as well as company-wide problems. Most people find their first one changes how they see arguments for good.