Interactive guides

An interactive guide to the pull-based replenishment system

Why shops run out of what sells while warehouses fill with what doesn’t, and how to size stock by replenishment time instead of forecasts. Move the sliders and see for yourself.

Mohit Saini · 12 min

Most supply chains suffer two problems at once: too much stock overall, and shortages of the items customers want. The usual fix is a better forecast. It rarely works, because forecasts at the level of one product in one location are wrong most of the time.

The Theory of Constraints, developed by Dr. Eliyahu M. Goldratt, takes a different route: hold a sensible buffer of stock, and refill it according to what was actually sold. This guide shows how to size that buffer, and why the biggest lever is time, not forecasting.

1. What a buffer must cover

A stock buffer has one job: keep the item available until the next delivery arrives. So it must cover the maximum demand you can reasonably expect within one replenishment time. Not the average: on an average day, half the days are busier.

“Maximum” means paranoid, not hysterical: the busiest stretch you can reasonably expect, not the wildest day in ten years.

Four things drive the size. Try them:

Notice which slider moves the buffer most. Demand you can’t control. Its variability you can’t control much either. But replenishment time is largely in your hands.

A distributor wants to hold less stock without more shortages. Which of these is most in its own control?

  • How long it takes to replenish each location after a sale
  • How much customers buy, and when they decide to buy it
  • How accurate next quarter’s product forecast turns out to be

Demand and its swings belong to the market. Forecast accuracy improves little however hard you try. Replenishment time is made of your own order, production and transport habits, and each of them can be shortened.

2. Order often, and the shelf shrinks

Replenishment time has three parts: the time until an order is placed, the time to produce it, and the time to move it. The first is often the longest, and the easiest to cut.

Here is the same sales rate with three ordering habits:

With monthly orders, up to a month of stock sits on the shelf. With daily orders, sending yesterday’s sales as today’s order, the shelf needs only a few days’ worth. Nothing else changed.

3. Hold stock where the swings cancel out

A shop sees its own demand jump around. A regional warehouse feeding twenty shops sees much smaller swings, because the shops’ peaks rarely happen together. So the TOC solution keeps most of the stock upstream, at the plant or a central warehouse, and refills shops frequently with small quantities.

The effect is less stock in total, and better availability at every shop.

4. Let the buffer tell you when to adjust

Demand changes. Rather than re-forecast every item, watch each buffer:

  • If it stays in the red (under a third left) too often, the buffer is too small: raise it.
  • If it stays in the green (over two thirds left) for too long, it’s too big: lower it.

This is dynamic buffer management. It turns thousands of forecasting decisions into a simple rule that follows real demand.

The pull solution in four lines

  1. Hold most stock centrally, where swings cancel out.
  2. Size each buffer for the “maximum” demand within the replenishment time.
  3. Refill frequently, according to actual consumption.
  4. Adjust buffers by how often they hit red or stay green.

Try running a supply chain yourself in the game below, first the usual way and then with these rules, and compare the stock and the shortages.