System Thinking

Is profit percentage the right yardstick?

Mohit Saini · 15 Jul 2024 · 4 min read

Is profit percentage the right yardstick?

In most business reviews, one number gets more attention than almost any other: profit as a percentage of sales. When it goes up, everyone relaxes. When it goes down, questions start, product portfolios are reviewed and “low-margin” products come under the knife.

It feels like a sensible measure. But is it a reliable way to judge whether a company has become more productive?

A good measure should avoid two errors:

  • A false alarm: showing a problem when there is none.
  • A false comfort: showing improvement when things are actually getting worse.

Let us test profit percentage against the first one.

A company with two products

Imagine a company that sells two product lines:

  • Product P (premium): high price, sold to a niche, where the company is a market leader. Every ₹100 of sales leaves ₹40 of throughput (sales minus truly variable costs, mainly material).
  • Product V (value): low price, sold to the mass market, where the company is one of many players. Every ₹100 of sales leaves only ₹12 of throughput.

Last year, the numbers looked like this (in ₹ million):

Sales Throughput
Product P 600 240
Product V 400 48
Total 1,000 288
Operating expenses 160
Profit 128 (12.8%)

This year, the premium market went flat. The sales team did well to hold P’s sales at the same level. But demand for the value product took off, and V’s sales doubled. Operating expenses rose modestly, mainly salaries, because the plant and the sales network already had spare capacity.

Sales Throughput
Product P 600 240
Product V 800 96
Total 1,400 336
Operating expenses 170
Profit 166 (11.9%)

Sales are up 40%. Absolute profit is up nearly 30%. But profit as a percentage of sales has dropped from 12.8% to 11.9%.

So, did the company do better or worse?

The trap

Faced with a falling percentage, management often does what feels logical: review the product portfolio. Fixed costs are allocated to each product. The value product, with its thin throughput, now shows a loss after allocation. The conclusion seems obvious: prune the value product to improve profitability.

Let us check what would actually happen. If the company drops the extra value sales, it loses ₹48 million of throughput. Operating expenses barely change, because salaries, rent and the plant cost the same whether the value line runs or not. Profit falls back towards last year’s level.

The value product was not the problem. The lack of growth in the premium product was the problem, and the value product has nothing to do with that. Without the value product, the picture would be worse, not better.

When does pruning make sense?

There is one situation where cutting a low-throughput product is right: when both products compete for the same constraint. If the plant’s capacity or the sales team’s time is fully used, every hour spent on the value product is an hour taken from the premium one. Then it makes sense to favour the product that earns more per hour of the constraint, until the constraint is expanded.

And here is a twist worth checking before you assume which product to favour. Suppose the plant’s capacity is the constraint. A unit of P earns ₹4,000 of throughput and takes 2 hours on the constrained line. A unit of V earns only ₹1,200 but takes 15 minutes. Per hour of the constraint, P earns ₹2,000 and V earns ₹4,800. The “low-margin” product is the more profitable use of the scarce resource. Ranking products by margin percentage would have pointed the company in exactly the wrong direction.

But if neither capacity nor the sales channel is limiting, the value product’s growth is not coming at the cost of anything. It is extra money entering the business.

A better measure of productivity

If profit percentage can raise false alarms, what should we look at instead?

Throughput Accounting, developed by Dr. Eliyahu M. Goldratt, offers a simple alternative: compare the growth of throughput (T) with the growth of operating expenses (OE).

In our example:

  • Throughput grew from 288 to 336, about 17%.
  • Operating expenses grew from 160 to 170, about 6%.
  • The ratio T/OE improved from 1.80 to 1.98.

The company generated much more money from a small increase in the money it spends to run itself. It made better use of its people, plant and network. It became more productive, even though profit percentage fell.

As long as throughput grows much faster than operating expenses, a company is getting more productive, whatever the profit percentage says.

Why this matters for growing companies

This is not an academic point. In emerging markets, growth often comes from lower price points and larger volumes. A company that has historically been a “high margin, low volume” player may find its growth coming increasingly from “lower margin, higher volume” products.

If such a company judges itself by profit percentage alone, it will keep raising false alarms, pruning products that bring in real money, and slowing its own growth. Measuring T against OE keeps the focus where it belongs: on bringing more money in, faster than the cost of running the business grows.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion