Retail · Sales
Brands vs retailers: ending the margin war

Brand owners and the retail chains that sell their products have argued about margins for as long as both have existed.
- The brand says: we created the brand, we built the demand, so most of the margin is ours.
- The retailer says: customers buy through us, we provide the shelf, the location and the shopping experience, so we deserve a bigger share.
Which side wins depends on who has more power. Where retail is fragmented into millions of small shops, brands have the upper hand. Where a few large chains control much of the market, retailers do. In those markets, big retailers squeeze suppliers on price, charge fees for shelf space and new store listings, and occasionally pull a brand off their shelves to make a point.
As retail consolidates, the balance tends to tilt towards the retailer. But whichever side is winning, the relationship stays tense, time-consuming and frustrating for both.
Attempts at a compromise
Both sides try to ease the pressure:
- Brands offer schemes to retailers. Retailers pick up extra stock under the scheme, can’t sell it all, and end up with slow stock that locks up money and reduces their next order. The scheme makes things worse for both.
- Retailers launch private labels to reduce their dependence on brands. But shoppers come to a multi-brand store to choose between brands. And making private labels means sourcing, manufacturing, packaging and marketing: in effect, becoming a consumer goods company.
So the margin war goes on. Is a genuine win-win possible?
What both sides really want
Neither side actually wants margin for its own sake. What each wants is a better return on investment. Margin is just the only lever each believes it can pull.
- The brand has invested in plants and marketing. To improve its return, it needs more sales at full price, from the same investment: no stock-outs, wider range on shelves, fewer discounts.
- The retailer has most of its capital tied up in stock. To improve its return, it needs more sales from less stock: higher stock turns. But retailers don’t believe they can cut stock without losing sales, especially when availability is already patchy. Display needs and minimum order quantities add to the difficulty.
Because neither sees a way to change stock or costs, margin becomes the battlefield.
The brand can make the first move
Here is where the deadlock can break. A brand that helps the retailer hold less stock while staying fully available gives the retailer a better return than any extra margin could.
Consider a typical situation. A brand’s depot is two or three days from a retailer’s distribution centre and delivers several times a week. With that supply time, the retailer should need perhaps ten days of stock. In practice, it holds three or four weeks, because supplies follow forecasts and availability is unreliable.
The brand can change this:
- Replenish the retailer’s distribution centres according to daily consumption, not forecasts. Each item has a target stock based on the supply time; whatever stores consumed yesterday is refilled.
- Prioritise by buffer colour, red items first, both in dispatch and in the brand’s own production.
- Apply the same pull logic all the way back: regional warehouses, the plant warehouse and production.
- Take back stock that doesn’t sell. For the brand, the risk is small; it can redirect the stock to where it sells. For the retailer, the risk of trying more of the brand’s range, including new products, disappears.
The results for both sides can be significant:
- The retailer holds far less stock of the brand, with near-perfect availability, and earns much more per rupee invested in that brand.
- The brand gets a wider range on the shelf, more sales, fewer emergency shipments, and releases its own working capital across the channel.
Look at it from the retailer’s ledger. Suppose the chain sells ₹1,000 million a year of this brand at a 20% margin, and holds four weeks of stock, about ₹60 million at cost. Every rupee in stock earns about ₹3.30 of margin a year. If the brand concedes two more points of margin, that rises to about ₹3.60. If instead the brand’s replenishment lets the chain hold ten days of stock, about ₹20 million, the same 20% margin earns about ₹10 per rupee of stock. No margin concession comes close.
When a supplier makes the retailer’s money work harder, the conversation changes. Fees and margin demands soften, because the retailer now has a better reason to favour that supplier than squeezing it.
Margin is what you argue about when you can’t see another way to make your money work. Show the other side another way, and the argument fades.