Supply Chain · Sales

Pull replenishment when wholesalers dominate the market

Mohit Saini · 8 Sept 2018 · 3 min read

Pull replenishment when wholesalers dominate the market

Whenever I explain pull replenishment (supply each point only what it has sold), a common reaction from people in consumer goods distribution is polite scepticism. “It works in books and case studies,” they say. “Our market is different. Half our volume goes through wholesalers.”

They have a point. Let me explain why, and what can be done about it.

When a good design fails

Picture a company that starts replenishing its regional warehouses according to consumption. It calculates buffers carefully, using replenishment time and demand variability, exactly as the method suggests.

Within a few months, the results are disappointing. The warehouses hold more stock than before, yet stock-outs have increased. Under pressure, the company goes back to forecast-based supply.

What went wrong? A closer look at the sales pattern answers it: half of each month’s sales happen in the last week. The familiar hockey stick.

This creates a dilemma for anyone sizing buffers:

  • Size buffers to normal demand, and they can’t cover the month-end peak.
  • Size buffers to the peak, and the warehouses overflow (and finance objects) for three weeks of every month.

Tweaking buffer sizes doesn’t solve it. We need to ask why the peak exists, when consumers buy steadily through the month.

The role of the wholesaler

In a country with millions of small retail shops, no company’s distributors can reach them all. Wholesalers fill the gap. They serve small and remote retailers who buy in tiny quantities.

A wholesaler’s business model is simple:

  • deal in a narrow range of fast-moving items,
  • work on very thin margins,
  • and turn money over as many times as possible.

Wholesalers buy in bulk, because bulk earns discounts. They pass part of the discount on to retailers to sell faster. And the best discounts and free goods are available in the last week of the month, when sales teams are desperate to hit targets.

Having spent heavily at month end, wholesalers have little cash for the first part of the next month. So they buy little early in the month and a lot at the end, every month. For companies where wholesalers account for most of the volume, a very large share of the month’s sales can arrive on the last day or two.

Everyone treats this as a fact of life. But a problem that has existed for a long time is not a law of nature. It is usually a sign that the parties involved are stuck in a lose-lose situation:

  • The company gets a hockey stick, high stock, and price undercutting as wholesalers sell into distributors’ territories, eroding the brand.
  • The wholesaler ties up cash in big month-end purchases and sits short of stock in the first weeks.

The first step: change what the discount rewards

The wholesaler’s real need isn’t to buy in bulk. It is to earn the discount that makes his thin margin work. Bulk buying is just the only way he can get it today.

So the first step is simple: keep the discount, but link it to what the wholesaler sells over the month, not to how much he buys in one go. Discounts can be calculated on cumulative purchases or on secondary sales reported over a period.

Now the wholesaler can buy in smaller lots, as he sells, without losing out. The month-end spike shrinks. Replenishment can be sized to steady consumption, not to an artificial peak.

The longer-term direction

Changing the discount structure is a crucial first step, not the whole solution. In the longer run:

  • Expand direct retail coverage, so that more shops are served by distributors who replenish small quantities frequently.
  • Make distribution profitable: with pull replenishment, distributors hold less stock, turn it faster and earn better returns, so they can invest in reaching more retailers.
  • Bring wholesalers into the system as partners, with the same pull logic, rather than treating them as a channel to dump stock into at month end.

With these changes, pull replenishment and wholesalers can coexist, and the month-end hockey stick slowly becomes a thing of the past.

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion