Supply Chain · Sales

Taking pull replenishment all the way to the neighbourhood shop

Mohit Saini · 19 Aug 2019 · 4 min read

Taking pull replenishment all the way to the neighbourhood shop

Every consumer goods sales manager knows the last week of the month. The target is still short. The stock in hand isn’t quite what the market wants. So he leans on his distributors to take a little more than they need, with an extra scheme or a longer credit period to sweeten the deal.

This is push. It shows up as a lopsided month: often half the sales in the last week, followed by a slow first week when distributors have no cash left to buy.

Most sales managers know the damage push does. Many know that supplying according to consumption would smooth sales, cut receivables and make planning easier. So why do so few companies actually switch?

The fear that holds companies back

The biggest reason is fear of losing sales. If we stop pushing and supply only what distributors actually sell, their cash is released. What if they spend it on a competitor’s products?

The way to address this fear is to pair pull replenishment with a win-win offer to the distributor:

  • The company supplies frequently, according to consumption, so the distributor needs far less stock of each item.
  • The cash this releases is used to stock a wider range of the company’s products. Most distributors carry only a small part of the range, because they fear getting stuck with items that don’t move.
  • For new items, the company can even offer to take back stock that doesn’t sell within an agreed period, removing the distributor’s risk.

The distributor turns his money faster and earns more. The company gets a wider range on the market. The cash doesn’t leak to competitors; it goes into more of the company’s own range.

Behind this offer, two internal changes are needed: production must make to consumption from a central warehouse instead of big monthly batches, and that central warehouse must hold stock (an aggregation point), not just pass it through.

Companies that do this typically see a strong sales jump in the first phase.

The trap after the first success

Here is what often happens next. Once the large distributors are on the programme, sales rise and targets rise with them. To make the next jump, the company needs to go further, to the retailer. That is hard. So it doesn’t.

Slowly, the old habits return. Pull for the first three weeks of the month, push in the last week to meet the target. Central warehouse availability suffers early in the month. Distributors’ stock creeps up, their returns fall, and they go back to limiting range and reach.

The biggest threat to any operating discipline is the pressure of a target that can’t be met without breaking it.

The only lasting protection is to have more sales opportunity than the target needs. And the largest untapped opportunity sits with the retailer.

Why the retailer matters most

At the retail shop, demand is the most fragmented and least predictable. This is exactly where pull has the most power. It is also where most companies have the least real reach: distributors short of cash tend to serve only a fraction of the shops in their area regularly.

But retail in many markets means millions of small, family-run shops with no computers and no daily sales data. Wholesalers, not distributors, serve many of them. So most companies conclude that pull at the retail level is impossible.

Good enough beats perfect

Daily data from every shop may be impossible. But look at where we are starting from: many retailers reorder an item once a month or less. Weekly is a huge improvement on monthly, and it is practical.

The approach:

  1. A regular visit. A representative of the distributor visits each shop on a fixed day, every week or fortnight, without fail. The distributor can afford this from the extra margin pull replenishment has earned him.

    Picture a distributor who used to carry about 45 days of stock, say ₹4.5 million. Supplied every few days from a nearby warehouse, he needs perhaps 15 days: ₹1.5 million. The ₹3 million released, at the interest he was paying, is worth several hundred thousand a year, enough to fund a couple of shop representatives and a small delivery vehicle, with money left over to stock a wider range.

  2. Order to a norm, not to a target. The representative checks the shop’s stock of each item against an agreed norm and orders only the difference. He is not a traditional salesman; his job is to make sure the shop never runs out and never overstocks.

  3. Show the retailer his own numbers. Our products are a small share of any shop’s business, so the shopkeeper has little feel for his returns on our category. Use his own purchase history to show him where he holds many weeks of stock of some items while others in the category are missing altogether. That turns a concept into something personal and convincing.

  4. Make it a process, not an art. Templates, training and a simple routine let a large field team roll this out across thousands of shops.

There is a useful side effect. When a wholesaler agrees to serve a defined set of shops on a regular schedule, he effectively becomes a distributor with a territory. Cross-territory price wars begin to fade.

Taking the less travelled road

Implementing pull at the retail level is more effort than stopping at distributors. Very few companies attempt it. But stopping halfway leaves the company exposed to the target pressure that pulls it back into push.

The companies that take pull all the way to the shop counter, with a regular visit, ordering to a norm and a convincing story for each retailer, build something competitors find hard to copy: wider reach, wider range and steadier sales.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion