Projects

Time, cost or quality: what matters most in a project?

Mohit Saini · 14 Sept 2019 · 3 min read

Time, cost or quality: what matters most in a project?

Project management textbooks tell us to measure and control three variables: time, cost and quality (including scope). Most project managers will tell you, from experience, that these pull against each other:

  • To speed up, you add resources, and the budget overruns.
  • To get a late project back on track, you trim scope or quality.
  • To control costs, you negotiate longer with vendors, and time slips.
  • To give the client more of what they “really” need, you add features, and both time and budget suffer.

So the accepted wisdom is to monitor and control all three, and compromise on none.

Managing everything, focusing on nothing

In practice, this is very hard to do. How much more time can you afford to spend negotiating a cheaper deal before it hurts delivery? Nobody knows at the time. You find out in hindsight.

So managers tend to focus on whichever variable is under the most pressure at that moment:

  • In many construction projects, costs are controlled tightly at the start while time slips away; near the end, money is spent freely to recover the schedule.
  • In software projects, features are dropped near a release date.
  • In plant shutdowns, planned items are skipped near the end when the restart date is at risk.

Trying to manage all three at once adds complexity and invites compromises throughout the project. In the end, none is managed well, and the conclusion drawn is that we must try even harder to control all three. Focusing on everything means focusing on nothing.

Are they really in conflict?

We assume the three variables are always at odds, like trying to hold three balls under water at once: push one down and another pops up.

But look at how projects actually unfold. Time is wasted early and recovered late.

  • A proposal takes months to finalise, but final testing is expected to finish “yesterday”.
  • Choosing a contractor takes months, but crews work round the clock to hit the handover date.
  • A delay in the client’s design approval is tolerated for days at the start, while the team works overtime at the end.
  • Work is started without proper preparation, to “save time”, which creates rework and poor quality.

Picture an 18-month plant project. The first seven months go into finalising the design, approvals and contractor selection, work that, done without waiting, might take ten weeks. Site work then gets eleven months for what was planned as fourteen. In the last three months, the team adds a second shift, air-freights equipment, accepts a contractor’s premium for night work, and defers a few “non-essential” items to after handover. The budget overruns and scope is trimmed, not because time, cost and quality were in conflict, but because five months were lost at the start, when nobody felt the pressure.

Most compromises on budget, scope and quality come from the pressure of time near the end. And that pressure comes from time wasted earlier.

Time drives the other two

So within the execution of a project, the three aren’t really in conflict. Managing time well tends to improve cost and quality as well. The negative trade-offs appear only once a project has lost control of time.

That matches experience: projects delivered early are usually also within budget and of good quality.

Why do so many people believe that less time means worse quality? Because they remember the times when deadline pressure forced shortcuts. True, if you try to do a task in less than its actual working time, quality suffers. But the real question is how the project got into that position. Look back, and you nearly always find time lost to interruptions, waiting and work that expanded earlier on.

A shorter project, run without wasted time, is a calmer project, and a calmer project makes fewer compromises.

Time also matters directly to the business. An earlier shutdown completion means earlier production. Shorter project lead times free people for more projects. Earlier commissioning of a plant brings forward its payback.

Focus on time, through flow

Critical Chain Project Management puts this into practice:

  • No intermediate task deadlines, so the deadline pressure that drives shortcuts disappears.
  • Buffer management shows where time is really at risk.
  • Daily focus on flow: issues that interrupt work are resolved quickly, without frantic expediting.

Organisations that manage time this way often find quality and cost improve along with delivery: fewer defects, smoother start-ups, better first-time results.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion