Supply Chain

Min-max is not a safety net: rethinking reorder points

Mohit Saini · 12 May 2025 · 5 min read

Min-max is not a safety net: rethinking reorder points

Almost every company that holds stock uses some version of the same rule. Each item has a minimum (the reorder point) and a maximum. When stock falls to the minimum, an order for a fixed “economic” quantity is placed, which should bring stock back up towards the maximum.

The rule is in every ERP. It is taught in every supply chain course. And yet the same companies complain of shortages and surpluses existing side by side.

Could the rule itself be part of the problem?

What min-max assumes

The reorder-point method rests on a hidden assumption: that the item will keep selling at the same rate that was used to calculate the minimum.

Let us see what happens when that assumption breaks.

Demand slows down. Stock falls slowly to the minimum and an order is placed. But at the new, slower rate, the stock on hand would have lasted far longer than the supply lead time. The order arrives on top of plenty of stock. Surplus.

Demand speeds up. Stock falls quickly towards the minimum. The order is placed only when the minimum is reached, but at the new, faster rate, the minimum runs out before the supply arrives. Shortage.

Real demand is rarely steady. So the same rule produces surpluses for some items and shortages for others, exactly the pattern most companies live with.

Put numbers to it. Take an item that sells 10 units a day, with a supply lead time of 10 days. The minimum is set at 120 units (ten days of demand plus a little safety), and the order quantity at 300.

  • Demand drops to 5 a day. Stock reaches 120 and an order for 300 goes out. At 5 a day, the 120 on hand would last 24 days, but the 300 arrive on day 10, when 70 are still on the shelf. Stock jumps to 370: about 74 days of sales sitting in the warehouse.
  • Demand rises to 15 a day. Stock reaches 120 and the order goes out. At 15 a day, the 120 run out on day 8. For two days the item is missing, just when it is selling best.

Same item, same rule, same software. One change in demand gives a surplus; the other gives a stock-out.

And the “economic order quantity”? In practice, ordering in big lots rarely saves much on ordering or purchase costs. What it does is delay the next order and reduce how quickly the system can respond to a change.

The real lever: replenishment time

To protect sales with less stock, we must reduce the time it takes to refill. Many managers believe that time is in the supplier’s hands. But a large part of it has nothing to do with how long the supplier takes to make the product. It comes from how and when we order: waiting for a reorder point, batching into an economic quantity, ordering once a week or once a month.

A different rule: order daily, refill to a target

The alternative is surprisingly simple:

  1. Give each item a target level: enough to cover the maximum likely consumption during its replenishment time.
  2. Every day, order exactly what was consumed yesterday. In effect, the minimum equals the maximum; there is no reorder point.
  3. Adjust the target when stock stays persistently too low or too high.

Back to the same item. If the supplier can refill within 10 days and the item sells up to 14 a day in a busy stretch, the target is about 140. When demand drops to 5 a day, orders drop to 5 a day the next morning; nothing arrives that wasn’t consumed. When demand rises to 15, orders rise to 15, and because stock is watched daily, a target that is too small shows up within days, not after a stock-out.

Compare that with the min-max rule, which swings between about 20 and 320 units even in steady times, and gives the 370 or the empty shelf we just saw when demand shifts. And if ordering daily cuts the replenishment time from 10 days to 5, the target can come down to about 70: the same protection with a fraction of the stock.

For this to work, a few old beliefs have to go:

  • “Daily orders mean tiny, expensive deliveries.” No. A daily order is just information: it tells the supplier what was used. How and when to deliver is a separate decision.
  • “Every order must be delivered within a fixed lead time.” No. What the customer actually needs is not to run out. When stock is comfortable, a slower delivery is fine. When stock is about to run out, a faster one is essential.
  • “The customer must decide the batch.” No. The supplier is better placed to combine requirements across many items, and even across customers, to fill trucks and production runs efficiently.

Make urgency visible

When a supplier receives daily orders for hundreds of items, how does it know which to send first? Share the stock situation with a simple colour code:

  • Red: stock below a third of the target. Send urgently.
  • Yellow: between a third and two thirds. Normal priority.
  • Green: above two thirds. Can wait.

The supplier now sees the relative urgency of every item every day and can plan production and dispatch to keep the customer out of red, while still optimising its own batches.

A different relationship with suppliers

This way of working needs a different kind of relationship. If every order is a fresh negotiation, with buyers playing suppliers against each other for the last rupee, no supplier will invest in keeping your stock out of red.

It works when the customer treats key suppliers as long-term partners, with pricing agreed for a period instead of order by order, and shares stock data openly every day. The supplier gains steadier, more predictable demand and fewer emergencies. The customer gains availability with less stock.

What a customer really needs from a supplier is not a fixed lead time. It is a promise never to run out.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion