Supply Chain

Full availability with half the stock: where the days really go

Mohit Saini · 6 Mar 2024 · 4 min read

Full availability with half the stock: where the days really go

Ask a consumer goods company how much stock sits between its plant and the retail shelf, and the honest answer is often three to four months: in the plant warehouse, regional depots, distributors’ godowns and retailers’ shelves.

Ask the same company whether its products are always available in the shops, and the answer is usually no. Some items are overflowing, others are missing.

How can four months of stock still lead to empty shelves?

High stock, poor availability

Two simple facts explain it:

  1. Forecasts get worse as you move closer to the shop. A national forecast may be reasonable; a forecast for one item at one distributor is mostly a guess.
  2. Sales teams push what is available to meet their targets, whether or not it is what the market needs.

So distributors and retailers end up holding plenty of stock, but the wrong mix. Their limited cash is locked in items that aren’t moving, while items that are selling run out. To order more, they need cash or credit, which is now stuck. Unavailability is created, even though the company’s own warehouses may be full.

And a stock-out at a shop costs more than one sale. The retailer offers another brand. If the customer likes it, the brand may lose that customer for good.

The dilemma

Management is caught between two valid needs:

  • Protect sales → keep more stock, everywhere.
  • Control costs → keep less stock, to save capital, space and write-offs.

Most companies swing between the two: a stock-reduction drive after a bad quarter for cash, then a stocking-up drive after complaints of lost sales.

The usual way out people look for is a better forecast. But forecasts at item and location level will never be accurate enough. Weather, festivals, competitor schemes and supply hiccups can’t be predicted. So let us look elsewhere.

Where the days go

The stock a location needs depends on two things: how fast the item sells and how long it takes to refill (the replenishment time). Sales rate is decided by the market. Replenishment time is decided by us.

So let us break down the replenishment time for a typical regional depot that orders from the plant once a month:

Component What it is Typical today
Order lead time Time between two orders for the same item ~30 days (monthly ordering)
Production lead time Time for the plant to make it, given monthly plans and big batches ~15–25 days
Transport lead time Travel time plus waiting for a full truck of that item ~5–10 days

Add a safety margin, and the depot needs close to two months of stock to stay available.

Now look at what each component really depends on:

  • Order lead time is purely a policy. If the depot orders daily (just send yesterday’s sales to the supplying point), it drops from 30 days to 1.
  • Production lead time disappears from the depot’s replenishment time if the depot is supplied from a plant warehouse that always has stock.
  • Transport lead time shrinks when the plant warehouse can fill trucks with a mix of items, so trucks leave more often without waiting for a full load of one item.

With these three changes, the depot needs perhaps 10–15 days of stock instead of two months, and still stays available.

“But won’t a plant warehouse add stock?”

This is the first objection everyone raises, and it is a fair one. We are adding a stocking point that didn’t exist before.

But the plant warehouse holds stock for the whole country at one point, and not all regions peak at the same time. Their ups and downs largely cancel out. So the central stock needed is much less than the sum of what each region would otherwise hold. Also, once production runs to refill the plant warehouse instead of chasing monthly plans and urgent orders, the plant’s own lead time drops.

Add it all up, and the total stock from plant to depot typically falls even with the new warehouse, while availability rises.

The benefits flow further down. Distributors a day or two away from a depot can hold a couple of weeks of the full range instead of months of the wrong range. Their stock turns several times faster, so their return on capital rises sharply, even on a thin margin.

What about changing demand?

Demand doesn’t stay still. Seasons, festivals and competitor moves all shift it. This is where buffer management comes in:

  • Each item’s target stock at each location is split into three zones: green (top third), yellow (middle) and red (bottom third).
  • If an item stays in red for longer than its replenishment time, demand has probably risen: raise the target by a third.
  • If it stays in green for too long, demand has probably fallen: lower the target by a third.
  • For known big events (a festival season, the summer peak for coolers), adjust targets manually in advance, then let buffer management take over.

There is no short-term forecast in this loop. Long-range forecasts are still useful for long-lead-time materials and capacity planning, but day-to-day stock follows actual consumption.

In short

Stop forecasting each location. Hold stock back, close to the source, and refill each location with what it actually sold.

Daily ordering, a plant or central warehouse, mixed trucks and buffer management together cut the replenishment time dramatically. Less time means less stock, and less stock in the right mix means better availability. Companies that make this shift often see sales grow while pipeline inventory roughly halves.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion