Retail

Growing a retail chain through franchisees, without passing on the problem

Mohit Saini · 17 Feb 2024 · 4 min read

Growing a retail chain through franchisees, without passing on the problem

For a retail brand that wants to grow, franchising looks like the perfect lever. The franchisee invests in the store and its stock. The brand grows its footprint without tying up its own capital. Operating costs for the brand rise only a little.

But there is a catch. Many organised retailers struggle to make money in their own stores. If the model doesn’t work for the brand, handing it to a franchisee doesn’t fix it. It only moves the problem onto someone else’s balance sheet.

The treadmill of break-even

Let us see why retail growth is so hard. Take a retailer earning a gross margin of 30% on sales, just at break-even, so fixed costs (rent, salaries, power) are also 30% of sales.

Next year, inflation pushes fixed costs up by 8%. To stay at break-even, gross margin must also rise by 8%, so sales must grow by 8% just to stand still.

This year Next year
Sales 100 108
Gross margin (30%) 30 32.4
Fixed costs 30 32.4
Profit 0 0

Now add competitive pressure: the retailer has to give up 2 points of margin to stay competitive, so gross margin falls to 28%. To cover the same 32.4 of fixed costs, sales must rise to about 116, a 16% increase, just to break even.

This year Next year
Sales 100 ~116
Gross margin 30 (30%) 32.4 (28%)
Fixed costs 30 32.4
Profit 0 0

That is a simple rule of thumb: a retailer at break-even must grow gross margin at least as fast as fixed costs, and any loss of margin percentage raises the sales growth needed. Few retailers grow existing stores that fast.

Two usual escape routes

Private labels raise the margin. But building a private label takes heavy brand investment, and customers come to a multi-brand store to see many brands, so the private label share can only go so far.

More stores raise sales. But each new company-owned store needs capital, takes years to pay back, needs local promotion, needs trained managers, and adds to the fixed costs that must be covered next year.

So franchising looks like the answer: someone else’s capital, someone else’s management, shared promotion, a long-term partner.

Why franchisees struggle

In practice, many franchise relationships are one-sided:

  • Slow stock is pushed onto franchisees.
  • Contracts are heavy: high entry fees, deposits and royalties.
  • Most of the business risk sits with the franchisee.

Why do brands write contracts like this? Often because they aren’t confident the franchisee will succeed, since their own stores turn stock slowly and earn poor returns. The contract protects the brand in case the store fails. And so, quite often, it does fail.

A model worth franchising

A franchise only lasts if the franchisee makes good money. That requires a store that turns its stock fast and earns a high return on investment. In retail, this comes from a pull-based supply chain:

  • a central warehouse that holds most of the stock and is always available;
  • stores replenished according to what they sold, frequently;
  • tight range control, with slow items pulled back to the central warehouse and offered to stores where they sell;
  • stock levels adjusted to each item’s actual demand and season.

The benefits multiply for a franchise network:

  • Stores need far less stock, so a franchisee’s investment is smaller and his returns are higher.
  • Less excess stock means fewer end-of-season discounts.
  • New stores can start with modest stock, because the central warehouse backs them up.
  • The success of the first few new stores generates the cash and confidence to open more.

Look at it from the franchisee’s side. Suppose he invests ₹2.5 million in fit-out and deposits and ₹3.5 million in stock: ₹6 million in all. His store sells ₹12 million a year and, after rent, salaries and royalty, leaves him ₹700,000. That is under 12% on his money, less than he could earn with far less effort elsewhere. If frequent replenishment lets the same store stay available on ₹1.5 million of stock, his investment falls to ₹4 million, and fewer end-of-season markdowns lift his profit to perhaps ₹900,000. His return rises to over 22%. That is the difference between a franchisee who stays and expands, and one who quietly looks for the exit.

With this in place, the brand can make franchisees a genuinely win-win offer:

  • a store format and range tailored to each location’s potential,
  • support to manage the range, including taking back slow stock,
  • and even a guaranteed minimum return on the franchisee’s investment.

Brands that have rebuilt their supply chain this way before franchising have been able to open new franchise stores rapidly, because franchisees could see they would earn well.

Retail is about location, location, location. Add one more: the right supply chain.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion