Retail

Should a retail chain grow fast or grow carefully?

Mohit Saini · 16 Nov 2022 · 4 min read

Should a retail chain grow fast or grow carefully?

Here is a puzzle about retail economics.

A manufacturer with a gross contribution (sales minus truly variable costs) of around 30% can often earn a net profit of 7–8%. A retail chain with a gross contribution of 40% or more often struggles to earn even 3%, if it earns a profit at all.

With such healthy mark-ups, why is retail so hard to make money in? And what does that mean for a chain that wants to grow?

The growth dilemma

Most retail chains grow by opening new stores. It is the most visible way to show rapid sales growth. But if the existing stores aren’t making money, every new store adds to the losses and the debt. Growing fast in this situation can put the company’s survival at risk.

So retailers face a dilemma:

  • Grow fast, to capture market share before competitors do.
  • Grow cautiously, to protect profitability and cash.

The way out lies in understanding what eats retail profits in the first place.

Where retail profits go

The biggest drain is the mismatch between stock and sales: too much of some items and too little of others, at the same time, in the same store.

  • Excess stock locks up money. Buyers have fixed budgets (open-to-buy), so money stuck in slow items means they can’t buy more of the fast ones. Sales are lost.
  • Slow stock takes shelf space that fast sellers need.
  • Slow stock eventually needs discounts, eroding the margin that looked so healthy on paper.
  • Some stock becomes obsolete and is written off.
  • Stock-outs lose sales directly. Customers don’t always accept a substitute, and repeated stock-outs send them to other stores.
  • Expediting to fix stock-outs disrupts normal operations and adds cost.

Both surplus and shortage lead to more of each other. The only way to improve stock turns consistently is to remove both at once.

Why forecasting can’t fix it

Every product goes through a life cycle, and at any moment items can be classified as:

  • Hits: in their peak selling phase,
  • Laggards: sales tapering off,
  • Dead: at the end of their life, and
  • Niche: low but steady sales.

The trouble is that items move between these groups unpredictably, and often faster than the supply lead time. A new style can become a hit within weeks of launch, while sourcing more takes months. Or a much-hyped launch can sell well for a week and then collapse.

Most chains try to manage this by improving forecasts and relying on the judgement of experienced buyers. But a hit or a flop is obvious only in hindsight. The environment remains unpredictable however much data we have.

Four areas that need fast reaction

Instead of predicting better, a retail chain should build the ability to react fast in four areas.

1. The supply chain

The speed of supply decides how much stock a store needs. If every store is supplied directly by many vendors, each with its own long lead time and minimum order quantities, stores end up buying far more than they need.

A central warehouse changes this. It holds stock from all vendors and supplies each store a mix of items, frequently, according to what the store sold. Store stock comes down. The central warehouse absorbs the swings across stores. Vendors benefit too: larger, steadier orders to one location instead of many small ones.

2. Stock norms that change with sales

A system that looks at sales daily can spot trends early. When an item keeps running low in a store, its target goes up; when it keeps sitting, its target comes down. Buying decisions change as soon as a trend shows, not at the end of the season.

3. New products

The usual practice is to spread a new product’s full first buy across stores. Once it is all placed, the ability to react is gone: one store sells out while another sits on stock.

A better way: place a minimum quantity in each store and keep the rest in the central warehouse. Refill stores as they sell. For risky launches, try the product in a few stores first and decide the wider rollout based on what happens.

4. Removing products

New items keep being added; the range keeps growing; slow items pile up in the tail. Two simple rules help:

  • Set a range limit for each category. When a new item comes in, the slowest one goes out.
  • Stop buying an item while it is still selling, if it is being phased out. Waiting until it is “dead” guarantees leftover stock.

So, fast or careful?

When these four areas are working, something important changes. Stores carry less stock, turn it faster and lose fewer sales. Each store earns a high return on investment. The capital needed to open a new store, much of which is stock, falls sharply.

At that point, the dilemma disappears. A chain with high-return stores can expand rapidly without exhausting its capital, because the growth funds itself.

A rough calculation shows why. Suppose opening a store needs ₹15 million for fit-out and deposits, and ₹10 million of stock. A chain of 20 stores therefore has ₹200 million tied up in stock. If faster replenishment lets each store stay fully available on half that stock, ₹100 million is released. At ₹20 million per new store (the fit-out plus the now-smaller stock), that is enough to open five new stores without borrowing a rupee, and each of them starts with the leaner, higher-return model from day one.

Grow fast only after each store makes money. Once each store does, growing fast becomes the careful choice.

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion