Operations · Supply Chain

After-sales service that customers actually feel

Mohit Saini · 9 Oct 2022 · 4 min read

After-sales service that customers actually feel

Cars, appliances and machines are far more reliable than they were a generation ago. Fewer breakdowns, fewer visits to the workshop. You might think that makes after-sales service less important.

The opposite is true. When products rarely fail, the few times a customer needs service stand out sharply. A great product experience can be undone by one bad visit to a service centre, and in a connected world, an unhappy customer’s story travels far.

So service must be both fast and consistently fast: the turnaround time for a repair or a scheduled service should be short for every customer, not just on good days.

At the same time, service is a profit centre. Spares and labour often earn a higher contribution than the main product, and many companies run them as a separate division with sales and profit targets.

Two goals that pull apart

These two goals tend to collide:

  • Great service means having the right parts on hand for every job, so the vehicle or machine isn’t kept waiting.
  • Good profits mean keeping parts inventory under control, because it is one of the biggest costs of a service operation.

With many models, each with thousands of parts, and with most parts used only when something breaks (not on a schedule), forecasting parts demand is very hard. Frequent new models, each with new components, make it harder still. Minimum order quantities from parts makers add surplus.

The result, in many service centres, is old stock alongside missing parts: parts several years old on the shelves, while the part needed today isn’t there.

What a missing part does to a service centre

A repair often needs several parts. If even one is missing:

  • the job waits, occupying a bay and a skilled mechanic’s time;
  • when the part arrives, the job jumps the queue, delaying others;
  • customers chase for updates and escalate;
  • the centre stops accepting new jobs to catch up, and the cycle repeats.

The service centre swings between calm and chaos, and delivery dates become unreliable. As vehicles age and need more repair-driven parts, reliability falls further.

The bigger damage

When genuine parts are hard to get at authorised centres, a parallel market fills the gap: independent mechanics, multi-brand garages and non-genuine parts. Customers who were supposed to stay loyal to the brand’s network drift away after a few good experiences elsewhere, and rarely return.

The authorised centre, meanwhile, earns less and holds more unwanted stock. Its return falls, opening new centres becomes harder, and the brand’s service reach shrinks.

Why the brand doesn’t see it

Many brands measure their parts supply by fill rate: the share of orders from service centres supplied in full within a set time. It sounds sensible, but it assumes the orders themselves are right. When forecasts are poor and centres order in fear of shortages, a high fill rate just moves the wrong parts faster. Some centres pile up surplus, others still run short.

A better measure is daily availability at the point of use: on any given day, what share of the parts a centre should stock is actually on the shelf?

Dampening the variability

The way out is not a better forecast, but mechanisms that absorb variability:

1. Order daily, based on consumption. Each service centre’s stock is refilled automatically according to what it used yesterday, instead of to a reorder point or monthly forecast. Priorities are set by how low each part’s stock is against its target. Suppliers can then send flexible, mixed loads rather than rigid minimum quantities of each part.

2. Stock in layers. Keep the fastest movers (mostly consumables) at every service centre. Keep slower parts at a city or regional hub that can reach centres quickly. Keep the slowest parts only at a central hub. Aggregating slow parts where demand is pooled gives better availability with far less stock. It may cost a little more in transport, but much less in inventory and lost jobs.

3. Limit the promise where needed. For very old models whose parts are no longer economical to make, be clear with customers about what can and can’t be supported, rather than stocking everything forever.

Full kit before the job starts

With parts reliably available, one more change lifts productivity: separate diagnosis from repair. Assess the job and list the parts first; assign it to a mechanic only when every part is ready. Jobs then flow without stopping, turnaround times fall sharply, and the same bays and mechanics complete more work each day.

Picture a workshop with ten bays, each able to turn around two jobs a day. If one job in five waits a day and a half for a missing part while it occupies its bay, two of the ten bays are blocked at any time. Daily capacity falls from 20 jobs to about 16, and the waiting jobs jump the queue when the parts arrive. With diagnosis done first and jobs entering a bay only when every part is ready, all ten bays work on jobs that can be finished. The workshop completes around 20 jobs a day with the same people, and nobody’s vehicle sits half-dismantled.

Service excellence and service profits aren’t enemies. Parts availability is what lets you have both.

When customers nearby start experiencing quick, reliable service, they come back, and they tell others. Sales grow from the same infrastructure, the network’s return improves, and the brand can afford to extend its service reach.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion