Supply Chain · Sales

What an open spare-parts market means for vehicle makers

Mohit Saini · 9 Mar 2019 · 3 min read

What an open spare-parts market means for vehicle makers

For a long time, many car makers kept a tight grip on spare parts and servicing. Independent garages struggled to get genuine parts and diagnostic tools. Warranties could be voided if a customer used an outside garage. Parts suppliers were often barred from selling the same parts in the open market. And with no competition, genuine spares could be priced high.

Competition regulators in several countries, including India, have challenged such practices and asked vehicle makers to make genuine parts and diagnostic tools available in the open market.

Vehicle makers have understandable concerns: customer safety, intellectual property, and the profits of their spares business. But an open market can be good business, if they approach it differently.

Two goals in tension

A vehicle maker’s spares and service business has two goals:

  • Excellent after-sales support, which helps sell more vehicles.
  • Good profits from spares and service.

Opening the market seems to trade one against the other: a wider service network for customers, but more competition for the spares business. Is there a way to have both?

The opportunities in an open market

1. The vehicles that have already left. Most vehicle makers focus on the warranty period. Once a vehicle is out of warranty, and especially once it changes hands, it usually stops visiting authorised workshops. Yet older vehicles need more parts and service, not less. A large share of vehicles on the road is many years old, while authorised workshops see mostly young vehicles. That ageing fleet is a big, poorly served market.

2. Stopping leaks. Where genuine parts aren’t available in the open market, they leak there anyway: from dealerships and service centres, often at lower prices to clear stock or meet parts targets. The maker’s intentions are defeated, and its margins suffer.

3. Squeezing out fakes. Poor availability of genuine parts is a prime reason for counterfeits. Fakes hurt the maker’s sales and reputation, and can endanger drivers.

4. Serving fleets. Taxi and fleet operators are a growing, demanding segment: they care about price, quality, safety and, above all, getting the right part quickly. Every day a vehicle stands idle costs them money. If they can’t get parts fast from the maker’s network, they look elsewhere.

Three ways to capture it

Distribute parts aggressively

Parts suppliers may want to serve the open market, but distributing to thousands of small shops in small quantities is not what they are organised for. They think in big business-to-business volumes and treat the aftermarket as a fallback during downturns. Customers generally prefer genuine “first-fit” parts if they are reliably available. So it is more profitable for the vehicle maker to build its own parts distribution into the open market than to prevent others from doing so.

Build a tiered service network

Authorised service centres can’t reach every town or every older vehicle. A tiered model can extend the brand’s reach:

  • Tier 1: multi-brand garages in places without an authorised centre, trained, certified and equipped to handle most minor and some major repairs.
  • Tier 2: smaller garages, trained and supported by Tier 1 garages or the nearest authorised centre.
  • Authorised centres continue to offer premium service for complex repairs and owners who want it, with the fastest parts availability.

Each tier sends jobs it can’t handle up the chain. More vehicles stay connected to genuine parts and to the brand.

Use pull-based distribution

None of this works if parts are pushed into the network with sales targets and month-end dumping. That would create the familiar mess: wrong parts in the wrong places, blocked capital, unhappy partners. Small garages, especially, can’t afford to tie up money in stock.

Pull distribution needs a few conditions:

  • Replace wholesalers with territory distributors, to deepen reach and stop cross-country dumping.
  • Keep the relevant range continuously available at the maximum number of retail points, so no one has to hoard.
  • Have distributors collect orders and replenish frequently.
  • Hold stock centrally, where demand from many locations is pooled, and refill downstream points according to consumption.

With high availability and low stock, distributors earn a strong return, which pays for the effort of serving many small shops and garages frequently.

An open market is a threat only to a maker that can’t keep its parts available. To one that can, it is a much bigger market.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion