Supply Chain

Make your suppliers allies in a downturn, not shock absorbers

Mohit Saini · 21 Dec 2022 · 4 min read

Make your suppliers allies in a downturn, not shock absorbers

In good times, long-term supplier partnerships look like a model of collaboration. Auto makers have dedicated suppliers set up nearby for just-in-time delivery, on pricing agreed for a period rather than per order. Many consumer goods and equipment makers have followed a similar path, outsourcing much of their manufacturing to “partner” vendors.

When everyone in the chain is making money, it all works. The cracks appear in a downturn, when sales fall, margins shrink and working capital comes under pressure.

What companies do to suppliers in a downturn

Under pressure for quick results, management turns to cost and cash, and the easiest place to find both is the weaker party in the chain: the supplier.

Squeezing prices. Buyers get aggressive targets to renegotiate. Experts are hired to prove what the “correct” cost should be. New, hungry vendors offer low prices to break into the vendor base. The threat of switching is used to force existing suppliers down.

Borrowing from suppliers. Companies stretch payment periods, formally or informally, and sometimes delay taking delivery of material already made to their own confirmed schedules.

Both feel like smart moves. Both backfire.

The short-term damage

Small, dedicated suppliers have fewer resources than their customers. When they aren’t paid on time, they cut raw material stocks and labour. Their deliveries become erratic.

You would expect parts availability to improve in a downturn: suppliers have spare capacity. Yet at many vehicle and equipment makers, it gets worse. Daily searches for parts and constant rescheduling increase. With assemblies needing parts from many vendors, cash trouble at even a handful of them can stop production. Meanwhile, the gain from paying suppliers later is wiped out by high, mismatched inventory.

The long-term damage

When the economy recovers and capacity is suddenly needed, suppliers who were squeezed take time to rebuild it, and the customer loses sales in the meantime. Some use the moment to raise prices to recover the cost of the longer payment terms. New vendors added during the downturn dilute every supplier’s commitment. Before long, the company is looking for “ideal partners” again, and swinging between “more vendors for competition” and “fewer vendors for coordination”.

The hidden money in the chain

There is a better way to find cash and margin in a downturn: look at how inventory flows through the whole chain.

Cash is locked in uneven flow. Look at inventory daily rather than at month end, and many companies see a wave: rising to a peak mid-month and flushed out at month end. Working capital is set by the peak, not the month-end figure. The same wave hits suppliers, who often hold finished goods made exactly to schedule that the customer hasn’t taken.

Margin is locked in wasted capacity. Where flow is uneven, capacity is built for the peaks and sits idle in the troughs. This waste never shows in monthly output reports, but it finds its way into suppliers’ prices. (A simple test: compare the actual working time of a supplier’s critical machine with the time available in the month.)

Both come from the same habit: planning in fixed cycles from forecasts. At the end of each cycle, the errors of the last one have to be corrected. The longer the cycle, the bigger the correction, and the bigger the wave.

Compare the two sources of cash. A company buying ₹1,200 million a year from suppliers stretches payment terms by 30 days. That releases about ₹100 million, once, and it lands as a cash crunch on the suppliers, who respond with erratic deliveries and, later, higher prices. The same company, looking at its own daily inventory, finds that the mid-month peak is ₹200 million above the month-end figure, and its suppliers carry a similar wave. Smooth the flow, and a large share of that ₹400 million across the chain can be released, permanently, with the suppliers better off rather than worse.

The way out: pull through the whole chain

Move from monthly or weekly schedules to a daily pull system across customers, operations and suppliers:

  • Replenish inventory according to actual consumption, keeping a steady level of stock in each part of the chain.
  • Share daily stock status with suppliers so they produce what is actually needed next.
  • Help suppliers apply the same flow methods on their own shop floors.

This reduces inventory throughout the chain, so there is no need to squeeze suppliers’ payment terms. It also reveals capacity at suppliers that was being wasted. Once flow improves, the real bottleneck at each supplier becomes clear, improvements can focus there, and output often rises substantially without new investment. Only when those gains are used up does it make sense to ask suppliers to add capacity, and then only at the constraint, which is a small, low-risk investment.

When suppliers make more money from the same assets, there is room to share the gains with the customer, rather than fight over them.

In a downturn, the cheapest cash and margin aren’t in your supplier’s pocket. They are in the flow between you.

Companies that use downturns to improve flow instead of squeezing partners come out with stronger suppliers, lower working capital, and the capacity to grab orders when the market turns.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion