Retail · Sales
Can brands with shop-based distribution compete with online marketplaces?

Over the last decade, online marketplaces have grown at a pace few industries have ever seen. For a consumer goods brand, this creates an uncomfortable dilemma.
- Stay out of the marketplaces, and risk losing customers who increasingly shop online.
- Go in, and the brand is usually asked for deep discounts. Now the same product sells online far cheaper than in the brand’s own dealer network. Dealers feel betrayed. Some threaten to stop stocking the brand.
Being in the online channel protects market share; being in it on these terms may destroy the traditional channel that still brings in most of the brand’s volume and margin. Caught between a rock and a hard place.
Why this time may be different
There are two common reasons for not worrying:
- Online is still a small share of sales in most categories.
- Modern retail (supermarkets and chains) was also expected to wipe out traditional trade, and it hasn’t. Most brands still sell the bulk of their volume through traditional shops.
But online marketplaces differ from modern retail in important ways. Modern retail has struggled to expand because it has to make profits. Many marketplaces have been willing to grow for years on investor money, prioritising customers and valuation over profit. And they have two structural advantages:
- Range. A marketplace can show a huge variety without holding all of it near every customer.
- Reach. With internet access and delivery networks spreading, it can reach customers far beyond any brand’s retail footprint.
If marketplaces become the dominant buyers of a category, power shifts to them. A brand that once sold to thousands of small distributors may find itself selling mainly to a few giant buyers, under constant margin pressure.
The strengths of the shop
Before giving up on traditional distribution, look at what a physical shop offers that an online marketplace can’t easily match:
- Look, feel and try before buying (for most categories other than books, music and some commodities).
- Instant possession. Walk out with the product today, instead of waiting for delivery.
And its weaknesses:
- Limited reach. The brand isn’t present in every shop where its customers go.
- Limited range. Each shop carries only a small part of the brand’s range.
If a brand can remove these two weaknesses, the shop becomes a formidable competitor to the marketplace.
Be wherever the customer is
Customers don’t spend all day at home browsing on a phone. They go to work, run errands, visit markets. Some convenience-store chains around the world have built such a dense network that it is almost impossible to go about one’s day without passing one of their stores.
In many countries, including India, that density already exists in the form of millions of small neighbourhood shops. The problem is the long tail: most of these shops are small, and brands find it inefficient to serve them directly. So they rely on wholesalers, who serve the tail patchily with a narrow range.
The way to win reach and range is to make serving the tail efficient through distributors:
- Move from forecast-and-push to pull distribution, so distributors hold perhaps a week or two of stock, refilled frequently from a nearby company depot, instead of months of the wrong stock.
- Use the cash this releases to add more of the range and serve more shops, including small ones, on a regular schedule.
A simple check shows how big the gap is. Pick one district. Count the shops in it that sell your category; count how many of them carry your brand at all; and in those that do, count how many of your items they hold. Many brands find they are present in less than half the relevant shops, and carry a small slice of their range in most of them. Every shop without the brand, and every item missing from a shop that has it, is a customer pushed towards an app. That gap, not the marketplace’s discount, is usually the first thing to fix.
Turn availability into an advantage online too
There is one more step. Brands with high availability at many stocking points across the country can open their own online store, delivering the same day or next day from a nearby distributor or depot, with a reliability that is hard for a marketplace to copy. The brand’s own store can also show its full range, more than any single shop.
Marketplaces, chasing faster delivery, are opening many local warehouses. In doing so, they lose some of the benefit of one large central stock. If they move stock between locations using forecasts and reorder points, they will face the same problem as traditional networks: too much of some items, too little of others, and unreliable delivery.
With its own channels strong, a brand can then sell on marketplaces on its own terms: at the same price as its shops, competing on product rather than discount, without undermining its dealers.
The answer to the online threat isn’t a bigger discount. It is being available, in full range, everywhere the customer already goes.