Projects · Personal Growth

Stop judging people by the plan

Mohit Saini · 23 Jun 2023 · 4 min read

Stop judging people by the plan

In most project organisations, a person’s performance is judged at least partly by one comparison: actual time taken against planned duration. Finish on plan, and you are efficient. Finish late, and questions follow, often into the annual appraisal.

Everyone also knows that projects are full of uncertainty, so actual times will differ from plans. That gap creates room for wrong conclusions, and for a lot of quiet resentment at work.

Two kinds of unfair judgement

When decisions are made under uncertainty, two kinds of error are possible: seeing a problem that isn’t there, and missing one that is.

Calling an efficient person inefficient. Someone finishes late against the plan. Does that mean they worked slowly? Not necessarily. They may have given their best against problems nobody could control, and their extra effort may have prevented an even longer delay. When people with low ratings say “the system caused it”, it isn’t always an excuse.

Calling an inefficient person efficient. Most estimates are “realistic”, which in practice means padded to survive typical problems. So a person who finishes on plan may simply have been lucky (no problems hit their task) and let the work expand to use all the hidden slack. Anyone who has seen a colleague praised for a “perfect” delivery record and quietly wondered how will recognise this.

Picture two engineers, each given a task planned at ten days. The first hits a vendor drawing error on day two, spends three days getting it fixed, and still finishes in twelve days by working weekends. The second’s task goes smoothly; the real work takes about five days, but the drawing is polished, reviewed twice and handed over on day ten. On the planned-versus-actual report, the first engineer is late and the second is on time. Anyone who watched the two tasks knows the opposite is closer to the truth.

Managers know these biases exist. That is why so many quietly adjust the numbers based on what they “know” about each person. Then the rating becomes a judgement dressed up as data.

Is there a fair benchmark?

What we really want to know is: did the person complete the task at the best speed the situation allowed?

Could we compare against the fastest time ever achieved for a similar task? No. The fastest time happens only when everything goes right at once, which is rare. Measured against that, almost nobody would ever look fast.

There is no fixed number that tells us whether a task was done at its best possible speed, because the circumstances are different every time.

A different approach: as fast as possible, under the circumstances

So let us drop the comparison with planned task durations altogether.

Think of a pit crew changing tyres in a motor race. Nobody gives each mechanic a personal target in seconds and rates them on it. Everyone simply works as fast as possible, and the team is judged on the result. The crew chief, watching closely, knows who did what.

Projects can work the same way: do each task as fast as possible, under the given circumstances. And it is management’s job to make those circumstances as good as possible:

  1. Remove bad multitasking. Frequent priority changes force people to switch tasks, which stretches every task. Fix priorities, and limit how much each person has open at once.
  2. Ensure a full kit before work starts. Missing drawings, specifications or decisions leave people waiting, or lead to rework. Prepare everything before the task begins.
  3. Resolve obstacles daily. Even then, unexpected problems will arise. A short daily review that surfaces obstacles and gets them removed quickly by the right level of management keeps work flowing.

When these conditions are in place, task times usually fall dramatically. Only then does it become possible to see whether any individual has a genuine performance issue, because the system is no longer hiding it.

How to evaluate people then?

Once the enabling processes are in place, what we need from each person is to keep working on the task without distraction until it meets its agreed completion criteria.

A manager who is involved in daily flow, and understands the circumstances of each task, can see who shows that behaviour and who doesn’t. Feedback can be given immediately, based on what was observed, the way a good coach gives feedback to players. There is no individual output number, only a team goal.

It may look less “objective” than a percentage. But feedback given on the spot, about behaviour the person knows the manager saw, is rarely disputed. And it builds the kind of trust that a spreadsheet of planned-versus-actual never does.

Measure the system first. Only when the system works can you fairly judge the people in it.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion