Retail

How a store slowly dies, and how to stop it

Mohit Saini · 28 Jul 2023 · 3 min read

How a store slowly dies, and how to stop it

Stores rarely fail overnight. A neighbourhood supermarket that opened to crowds can take two or three years to wind down. By the time the decision is made to close it, the cause is usually long forgotten. The store manager blames a competitor’s discounts, rising costs, or “weak demand in the area”.

But the area was studied before the store opened. The costs were estimated. The competition was known. So what really changed?

The customer with a list

Think of a regular grocery shopper. She comes once a week with a list and wants to finish it in one trip.

One week, two items on her list are missing. A minor nuisance. The next week, three different items are missing. The week after, another one. Each time, she has to make an extra stop elsewhere.

Eventually, she tries the other store down the road and finds everything there. She starts going there first.

And she doesn’t keep it to herself. Grocery shopping comes up in conversations with neighbours and friends. A few of them notice the same thing and change their habit too. Customer loss doesn’t grow in a straight line. It accelerates.

The spiral

Here is how one problem feeds the next:

  1. Items go missing from time to time, not always the same ones.
  2. Regular customers start shopping elsewhere, and word spreads.
  3. Footfall falls, but the store’s stock stays the same, so stock turns drop.
  4. Money gets locked in items that aren’t moving. The category buyer, short of budget, delays orders for items that are out of stock.
  5. More items go missing.
  6. To free up money, slow items are given prime shelf space and discounts. The shelves fill with tired, unpopular stock, and the store starts to look old.
  7. Even fewer customers come. Back to step 2.

Each turn of the spiral is small. Together, they can sink a store that had every reason to succeed. And when a few stores close, the stock and fixtures written off can hurt the whole chain.

Early warning signs

Store managers can watch for the spiral before it takes hold:

  • Stock-outs of regular items, even at low levels, appearing on different items each week.
  • Average stock that is high relative to the supply time. If the warehouse is a day away and the store holds two weeks of stock, while some items are still missing, the mix is wrong.
  • Buyers postponing orders because the category budget is “used up”.
  • Shelf space given to clearance and discount items creeping up.
  • Footfall drifting down while nothing has changed outside the store.

Breaking the spiral

The root of the spiral is inconsistent availability. The obvious fix (carry more stock) makes the money problem worse. The real fix is full availability with less stock:

  • Send daily sales from the store to the supplying warehouse.
  • Replenish exactly what was sold, every day or two.
  • Keep the warehouse itself always available, by holding stock there and refilling it from suppliers on actual consumption.
  • Give each item a target of a few days’ sales, and adjust it with buffer management as sales change.

With a warehouse a day away, a store can stay fully stocked on about a week of sales. The money released is used to widen the range, which brings more customers, not fewer.

A note on min-max systems, which many chains use: when an item suddenly sells faster, the reorder is triggered at the minimum, but the stock runs out before the delivery arrives. The usual fix is to raise the minimum, which raises stock everywhere. Daily replenishment to a target avoids this trade-off.

A store doesn’t die from one bad month. It dies from small, repeated disappointments. Fix those, and the spiral turns the other way.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion