Supply Chain · Sales
The wholesaler problem every distribution company knows

Ask the regional sales managers of an auto-parts or consumer goods company about their biggest headache, and many will name the same thing: stock from one big trading hub turning up in their territory at prices their own distributors can’t match.
In most large markets, there are a few such hubs: bustling wholesale bazaars where traders buy in huge quantities and sell anywhere in the country. One hub can account for a much larger share of a company’s sales than its share of actual consumption. The sales manager responsible for that hub always meets his targets. His colleagues elsewhere are not fond of him.
Let us understand how this happens, and why it is a symptom, not the disease.
Why would a retailer buy from a thousand kilometres away?
A retailer’s logic is simple. He sells at the printed price. To earn more, he needs to buy cheap, including freight.
Normally, buying from the nearest distributor is cheapest, because freight is low. So when a retailer skips his local distributor and orders from a trader in a distant hub, there is only one explanation: the hub price is low enough to cover the long-distance freight and still beat the local price.
How can that be, when both the local distributor and the hub trader get the same margin from the company?
The hub trader’s model
The hub trader is not really a distributor. He is a speculator in stock and money. His model has two parts:
- Buy big and cheap. He buys large quantities at the best possible discount, usually at month end, from sales managers who need volume to meet their targets.
- Sell cheaper still. He sells at a thin margin, sometimes almost at cost, to turn his money around as fast as possible. Often he holds no stock at all, billing goods that ship directly from the company’s depot to his buyers.
It is excellent business for the trader, and for the hub’s sales manager who meets his numbers. It is also good for retailers who can buy in the quantities that make the deal worthwhile.
The arithmetic is simple. Say a part has a printed price of ₹100 and the company sells it to every distributor at ₹80, leaving ₹20 for the distributor and retailer to share. A local distributor sells to the retailer at about ₹86, keeping ₹6 to cover his salesmen, delivery and credit.
The hub trader buys the same part at month end with an extra 7% discount: about ₹74. He doesn’t run salesmen or vans, so he is happy to sell at ₹76. Freight to a retailer a thousand kilometres away adds perhaps ₹3. The retailer’s cost: ₹79 from the hub, against ₹86 from his own distributor down the road. No wonder he orders from the hub.
What it does to the company
For the company, the picture is very different:
- Price wars inside its own brand. Local distributors cut prices to defend their volume. The brand starts behaving like a commodity.
- The market price is set by speculators, based on how much stock they cornered and at what discount, not by the company’s pricing strategy.
- Uneven distribution. Spiky bulk sales create surpluses in some parts of the country and shortages in others, which competitors happily fill.
- Distributors lose faith. Genuine distributors, who invest in serving a territory, see their margins eroded and sometimes walk away.
All the money spent on advertising and brand building is undermined by whoever controls the hub’s price that week.
Yet companies find it very hard to act. Stopping supplies to the hub means an immediate drop in sales. What happens to this month’s target?
The real cause: push
Why do hub traders thrive while genuine distributors struggle? The answer lies with the companies themselves.
In a push system, companies sell big lots at month end, with discounts, to meet targets. Availability of individual items suffers through the rest of the month. Selling agents are left with unwanted stock, and the fastest way to get rid of it is to dump it cheaply to traders.
Meanwhile, a genuine distributor who wants to serve his market with small, frequent supplies faces two problems: the company can’t reliably supply him the items he needs through the month, and he has to fight hub stock in his own territory.
Push makes distribution a poor business, and speculation a good one.
The way out: make distribution a good business
The way out is to switch from push to pull:
- Supply each distributor what he sold, frequently, from a central stock that is always available.
- Keep the full range available through the month, so distributors can serve retailers in small lots.
- As distributors hold less stock and turn it faster, their return on investment rises, and they can invest in reaching more retailers.
Once genuine distributors are earning well and the company’s sales through them are growing, the company has options. Many traders can be persuaded to become real distributors with a defined territory. Where they won’t, the company has the confidence to replace them, because it is no longer dependent on their month-end volume.
This takes collaboration across production planning, sales planning and distributor relationships. But it is a far better place to be than permanent conflict between the company’s own channels.