Supply Chain · Sales
Stock is down, availability is up, so why did sales fall?

Here is a puzzle worth working through if you are moving to pull replenishment. Read the situation, form your own answer, and then read on.
The situation
A consumer goods company buys its products from a manufacturing partner and sells through distributors, who supply both retailers and wholesalers. A year ago, it started pull replenishment.
On the supply side, the results are excellent:
- Inventory across the chain is down sharply, close to half.
- Shortages are down sharply. The buffer reports at the central warehouse and distributors show mostly yellow, a few greens, very few reds.
- Distributors are on the new offer, earning better returns on their investment and turning their stock faster.
But on the sales side:
- Most of each distributor’s sales still go to wholesalers; direct sales to retailers are well under half.
- The company’s total sales are down about 8% on last year.
- Its product mix has shifted. The top 6 of its 60 items used to make up about 80% of sales. Now it takes the top 10 to reach 80%.
Yet, surprisingly, the company has moved from a loss to a profit, without any cost-cutting drive.
Three questions:
- Why did sales fall?
- How did the company become profitable with lower sales?
- What explains the change in product mix?
Take a minute before reading on.
Why did sales fall?
The textbook explanation is that distributors were overstocked from years of push. When buffers were set to the new, shorter replenishment time, many items were above their norm, so the company shipped less while the excess cleared.
That explains a dip of a few weeks or months. It doesn’t explain a whole year. And frankly, a sales dip should not be accepted as the normal price of moving to pull. A major change should produce visible benefits early, or it will lose support.
A better transition does three things:
- Redeploy released cash immediately. When we stop pushing the usual items, the distributor’s cash is freed. Use it right away to stock items he never carried.
- Roll out in waves. Bring one group of distributors onto the new offer at a time. While their excess stock clears, the others continue as before. By the time the next group starts, the first group’s sales are already rising.
- Expand reach fast. Before the offer is presented, map every potential retail outlet in each distributor’s area. Use the released cash to fund salespeople and delivery to cover those outlets. More outlets mean more sales, which earns more cash to invest further.
The company in our puzzle did not expand retail reach quickly enough. And it probably took a double hit: wholesalers, sensing that pull would hurt their bulk-buying model, cut back their purchases. With retail growing too slowly to make up the gap, total sales fell.
How did profit rise when sales fell?
Two effects explain it.
First, schemes and discounts disappeared. Pull doesn’t need quantity discounts to force stock into the channel. Every rupee of discount removed goes straight to throughput.
Second, the product mix shifted in the company’s favour. This needs a closer look.
The “physics” of the product mix
In most multi-product companies:
- High-volume items are where the company has a large market share and fights hard on price. Their throughput per unit (price minus truly variable costs) is usually below the company average.
- Low-volume items are often categories where a competitor leads. For us they are “slow movers”, but their throughput per unit is often above average.
Now add schemes. Discounts are meant for slow items, but in practice the big items get pulled into every scheme too. Combine thin throughput with heavy discounts, and a company can end up losing money on every unit of its best-selling products, without realising it until the annual numbers arrive.
In our puzzle:
- Wholesalers mostly buy the big items. As wholesale sales fell, volume of those low-throughput, heavily discounted items fell.
- Pull replenishment widened the range in retail, so sales of high-throughput “slow movers” rose.
- Discounts were removed.
So total sales dropped, but the money the company actually made from its sales rose. The loss turned into a profit.
A simplified version of the numbers shows how this works (₹ million, per year):
| Last year | This year | |
|---|---|---|
| Big items: sales | 800 | 640 |
| Big items: throughput before schemes (12%) | 96 | 77 |
| Schemes and discounts | 60 | 0 |
| Other items: sales | 200 | 280 |
| Other items: throughput (30%) | 60 | 84 |
| Total sales | 1,000 | 920 |
| Throughput after schemes | 96 | 161 |
Sales fell by 8%. Throughput after schemes rose by about two-thirds. With operating expenses roughly unchanged, that is enough to turn a loss into a profit.
Sales volume and profit are not the same thing. A change in mix can matter more than a change in volume.
The lessons
- A sales dip during the move to pull is not inevitable. Redeploy cash, roll out in waves and expand reach early.
- Watch throughput by product, after all discounts and schemes, not just sales by product.
- “Slow movers” may be the most profitable items you have. Pull replenishment and wider range give them the chance to prove it.