Supply Chain

Fresh is the new available: managing products with a shelf life

Mohit Saini · 31 Aug 2021 · 5 min read

Fresh is the new available: managing products with a shelf life

Watch shoppers in any supermarket aisle with juices, biscuits, packaged snacks or medicines. Many pick up two or three packs and compare the dates before choosing one. Some reach for the packs at the back of the shelf, knowing the newest stock is usually there.

For any company selling products with a “best before” date, freshness has become part of availability. A pack that is close to expiry is, for many customers, as good as not there.

What stale stock costs

Poor freshness hurts a company in several ways:

  • Lost sales and lost customers. A shopper who finds only near-expiry stock postpones the purchase or switches brands. Repeat the experience a few times, and that customer may not come back.
  • Discounts and write-offs. As stock ages, companies push it down the chain at heavy discounts. Distributors and retailers accept it only if they are confident of selling it in time, and only at a price. What can’t be sold must be destroyed.
  • Slower new launches. Since a new product’s demand is the hardest to forecast, distributors and retailers fear being stuck with expiring stock. They accept smaller quantities, launches slow down, and some products are labelled failures before customers have really seen them.

Add these up, and many companies lose several percent of their sales to the freshness problem every year.

Where the time goes

A pack loses freshness while it waits. That waiting has two parts:

  1. The time it takes to reach the shelf after it is made.
  2. The time it sits on the shelf before someone buys it.

Companies usually blame the second part on things they can’t control: brand strength, the retailer’s effort, consumer taste. But if the first part is fixed and the product sells at all, the freshness problem largely disappears.

Physically, a pack can reach almost any shop in the country within two to three weeks of being made. Yet some packs are found in the market five or six months after manufacture. Why?

Because in between the plant and the shelf are several stocking points (a transit warehouse, a forwarding agent, a distributor, a retailer), and at each point, the pack waits. The total waiting time equals the stock held along the chain.

An average of “two months of stock in the chain” sounds acceptable. But averages hide the truth: some items are out of stock while others have many months of stock sitting somewhere.

Picture a biscuit with a six-month shelf life. Many retailers won’t accept packs with less than about a third of their life left, and shoppers avoid them anyway. So every pack must reach the shelf within about four months of manufacture, and sell soon after. If the chain holds two months of stock on average, but some items sit for five months at a distributor because they were pushed in a scheme, those packs arrive at the shop with a month of life left. They are discounted, returned or destroyed. With three to four weeks in the whole chain, every pack reaches the shelf with most of its life ahead of it.

The freshness-availability conflict

Most companies are stuck in a familiar tug of war:

  • The supply chain team fights for freshness: cut stocks, watch ageing, ration supplies.
  • The sales team fights for availability: more stock, everywhere, to avoid stock-outs.

Whoever has more clout this month wins, and the compromise shifts back and forth.

Several things make it worse: the sheer number of item-location combinations to manage; launches that flood the market on a forecast; seasonal spikes and promotions that push big stocks to the bottom of the chain; shoppers who pick the newest packs, leaving older ones behind; and reluctance to take stock back once a sale has been booked.

Treating symptoms

The common responses are:

  • Extend shelf life, through better packaging or formulation. Useful, but it accepts the slow supply chain as a given.
  • Improve forecasts, with more sophisticated tools and real-time data. Forecasts at item and location level remain unreliable.
  • Build many small plants close to each market. This shortens the chain, but at the cost of economies of scale.

None of these resolves the conflict. We need a design that gives both high availability and high freshness.

Designing for freshness and availability

Go back to first principles. Two questions decide everything:

How much stock should each point hold? Enough to cover the maximum likely demand during the time it takes to be refilled from the point above it. If the point above always has stock, that time is just the transport time.

How should stock move? According to what was actually consumed, not to a monthly forecast.

This leads to a design that looks very different from the usual one:

  • The plant warehouse holds most of the stock, instead of pushing everything out immediately. Demand from the whole country is pooled there, so forecasts are most reliable at that point.
  • Production refills the plant warehouse daily, based on what was consumed, with short production cycles. When the plant sees only the near term, campaign cycles shrink, and so does production lead time.
  • Every link orders daily what it consumed, and is replenished frequently, with priorities set by buffer status (red first, then yellow, then green).

With this design, each point holds only a few days of stock: the plant warehouse a few days of production, forwarding agents and distributors about the transport time to them, retailers a few days. Total stock in the chain can come down to three to four weeks, while availability goes up. No pack on the shelf is much older than that.

What about very short shelf lives?

For products that last only a couple of weeks, the same logic tells you how many plants you need. The shorter the shelf life, the smaller the area one plant can serve. Within that area, use small and frequent dispatches (daily or every other day) to keep total stock at just a few days.

In short

Freshness is lost in waiting, and waiting is just another name for stock in the chain.

Hold stock centrally, refill each point with what it sold, and keep the time between plant and shelf short. Freshness and availability stop being enemies.

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion