Supply Chain

How a small dip at the dealer becomes a crash at the sub-supplier

Mohit Saini · 14 Apr 2021 · 4 min read

How a small dip at the dealer becomes a crash at the sub-supplier

A vehicle maker sits at the top of a large pyramid of suppliers: tier-1 suppliers making assemblies, tier-2 suppliers making parts, tier-3 suppliers making castings, forgings and mouldings. A vehicle has thousands of parts. No industry is coupled so tightly: every supplier’s volume moves with the vehicle maker’s production.

That coupling means the vehicle maker’s way of working ripples through the entire pyramid, and the ripples grow as they travel.

Two everyday stories

A promotional surge. A vehicle maker wants to finish the financial year strongly. It launches a promotion on one model and, at short notice, plans to produce it at three or four times the normal rate for a quarter. One part needs an imported raw material that normally comes by sea in about two months. To meet the surge, the supplier air-freights the material at a heavy premium, borrows to pay for it on arrival, and invests in extra capacity. The vehicle maker hits its year-end number. Then, with dealers full of that model, production falls well below the old rate. The supplier is left with months of expensive material, extra capacity and higher debt. The surge that looked like good news for everyone wiped out its profit on that part.

A recovery that hurts. After a downturn, vehicle production picks up again. A tier-2 supplier should be relieved. Instead, its cash is gone: during the slump it couldn’t cover its fixed costs, borrowed more, and laid off skilled workers. Now it can’t buy enough raw material or find enough people even for volumes it handled easily before. Changing schedules from its tier-1 customer force it to buy new material while its scarce cash is stuck in material bought three days earlier. Its deliveries slip, and everyone threatens everyone else with taking business elsewhere.

Industry insiders can tell many such stories.

Pull at the top, push below

Most vehicle makers proudly run a pull system at their own line: they hold a day or two of parts and draw components according to actual consumption. But they give suppliers monthly forecasts and expect them to push to plan.

Actual vehicle production always differs from the forecast. And since a vehicle can’t be built if even one part is missing, the vehicle maker, wanting to keep its line busy, loads whichever models it can build with the parts it has. Some parts are suddenly needed at several times their average daily rate.

Suppliers who miss these swings get penalised, so they protect themselves with stock. Each level holds more than the level above it:

  • the vehicle maker holds a couple of days of parts,
  • tier-1 suppliers hold several weeks of finished goods and parts,
  • tier-2 suppliers hold a month or more of finished goods and work in progress, plus more raw material.

Despite all this stock, the chain still expedites daily, because the stock is the wrong mix.

When demand turns down

In growing markets, the chain muddles through. In a downturn, it turns on itself:

  1. Dealers’ stocks start rising: the first sign of slowing demand.
  2. Under pressure to keep plants busy, vehicle makers keep producing to forecast for another month or two. By the time they cut production, the pipeline holds months of vehicles.
  3. Tier-1 suppliers, also wanting to use capacity, keep producing a little longer. Then they supply from their swollen stocks while their own production collapses.
  4. Tier-2 suppliers see orders fall even further and for even longer. Their income no longer covers fixed costs. They lay off workers and use material money to pay salaries and interest.
  5. When demand recovers, the deepest tiers are the last to restart. They lack cash and people. The vehicle maker can’t ramp up until its slowest supplier does.

A dip of a few months at the vehicle maker becomes a crash lasting the better part of a year at the bottom of the pyramid. This is the bullwhip effect, and its driver is the lag in reacting to real demand. Every forecast-based link and every monthly target adds to that lag.

Extending pull through the whole chain

The way out is to apply the pull principle that vehicle makers already use at their own lines all the way through the chain, from dealers to the deepest supplier tier:

  • The vehicle maker holds a designed finished-vehicle buffer at its central warehouse, the point where demand from all dealers is pooled and most predictable.
  • Dealers are supplied according to actual sales, not pushed to meet primary targets. Dealers hold stock only of models customers won’t wait for.
  • Plants produce to refill the central buffer, prioritising models whose buffer is in red, and never producing beyond the buffer. Some lines may pause briefly when demand falls, which is far better than a long shutdown later.
  • Tier-1 suppliers hold their own buffers sized to the vehicle maker’s daily use and their production lead time, supply daily from those buffers, and produce to refill them.
  • Tier-2 suppliers do the same for tier-1’s parts and raw material buffers.
  • Dynamic buffer management adjusts each buffer as consumption changes, so any shift in vehicle sales reaches the deepest tiers within days, not months.

This builds on the same flow logic as the Toyota Production System. The difference is that it doesn’t require the vehicle maker to smooth its customers’ demand (which few can), because the central buffer and dynamic buffer management absorb real variation.

The bullwhip isn’t caused by the market. It is caused by how slowly the chain hears the market.

Only the vehicle maker can start this change, because the flow begins between dealers and the vehicle maker. But the one that does protects not just itself but its entire cluster of suppliers.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion