Supply Chain · Retail

More variety without more chaos

Mohit Saini · 17 Jun 2022 · 5 min read

More variety without more chaos

Walk into any paint shop today and ask for “white”. The shopkeeper will show you a fan deck with thirty shades of it: brilliant white, ivory, cream, off-white, warm white, cool white… A generation ago, white was just white.

Most customers had no idea they preferred “warm white with a hint of grey” until someone showed it to them. Once they saw the choice, many found their own favourite.

This is what variety does. It creates new preferences, and brands use it to win customers from competitors. But it has a cost that marketing teams rarely see.

Variety splits demand

When one product becomes ten variants, the total demand doesn’t multiply by ten. It gets split across the ten. Demand that used to be large and steady for one item becomes small and erratic for each variant.

This shows up in the familiar “long tail”. In many categories today, the top 20% of items no longer account for 80% of sales. They account for perhaps 30–40%. The rest comes from a long list of items, each selling a little.

For the supply chain, this is a serious problem:

  • Production gets smaller volumes per item, but is still measured on efficiency, so it wants big batches. Marketing wants small quantities of many items. The tension grows every year.
  • Forecasting gets harder. Erratic demand at item level is almost impossible to predict.
  • Distribution suffers most. When every variant is pushed out to every distributor and store, each location ends up with a few pieces of everything. Some sell, many don’t. Inventory turns fall, cash gets locked up, and the retailer’s budget for new stock shrinks.

Put numbers to it for a single store. Suppose the store sells about 70 cans of “white” a week, give or take 20. If it is refilled weekly, holding around 100 cans keeps it available: a week’s sales plus a cushion for a busy week.

Now the same 70 cans are spread across ten shades of white, about 7 a week each. But demand for each shade swings much more, relative to its size: one week 2, the next week 15. To stay available on every shade, the store needs perhaps 15 to 20 of each, or 150 to 200 cans in all. Same sales, nearly twice the stock, and still the occasional empty slot when a shade has a good week. Multiply that across thousands of stores and the cost of variety becomes visible.

The ideal place to hold variety

From a purely statistical point of view, the best place to hold a wide range is one central location. When demand from the whole country is pooled, the ups and downs of individual stores cancel out. Large online retailers use exactly this advantage: one large warehouse, the whole range, very high stock turns.

But many products need to be seen, touched or tried before people buy them: clothes, furniture, paint, electronics. These products must reach physical stores. So the question becomes:

How do we take variety to the point of sale without letting it destroy inventory turns?

I would suggest three strategies, used together.

Strategy 1: pull, don’t push

If demand is going to be fragmented anyway, at least don’t make it worse.

  • Hold most stock centrally and send it to stores only as they sell, in small quantities, frequently.
  • Shorten replenishment time so that stores need less stock to stay available.
  • Take back what doesn’t sell. In a store, even one unit of a slow item can represent months of stock. Moving it to a store where it sells, or back to the warehouse, frees space and money for items that do sell. The extra freight is small compared with the sales gained.

Strategy 2: give creativity a boundary

Does every new variant actually win new customers? Up to a point, yes. Beyond that point, extra variety stops creating new preferences and simply splits existing demand further. Nobody knows exactly where that point is.

Two ideas help here:

  • Design from common building blocks. In most consumer products, variety is created late in the process: a few base materials become many finished items. If designers mostly use a defined palette of base materials (certain yarns, fabrics, bases or components), new designs can be made quickly from stock. Designs outside the palette are still allowed, but everyone knows they will take longer.
  • Offer different service levels. Keep the proven, fast-moving range available at every store. Keep the long tail only at the central warehouse, available within a few days. Review regularly: items that start selling move into the store range; items that stop selling move out.

Strategy 3: sell variety you don’t stock

The second strategy only works if stores can sell items they don’t physically hold. That needs two things.

Props that recreate the experience. Customers decide using some mix of look, feel and trial. If those can be offered without the actual stock, the stock can stay central:

  • a furniture store shows one sofa, with large swatches of every upholstery fabric that customers can drape and touch;
  • a paint store uses large painted panels instead of tiny chips;
  • a bookshop lets customers browse a sample before ordering a title it doesn’t stock.

Salespeople who trust the supply chain. A salesperson will never push an item he isn’t sure will arrive on time. He is the one who faces the customer if it doesn’t. So the central warehouse must deliver the long-tail items reliably, every time. Once salespeople trust it, they sell the “virtual” range, and the company learns the true demand for those items.

Have the cake and eat it too

The usual fight between marketing (“we need more variety”) and supply chain (“cut the range”) is rarely settled by cutting SKUs from a spreadsheet. A product deserves a fair chance in front of customers before it is dropped.

Pull-based replenishment, bounded creativity and props at the point of sale give every item that chance, without drowning the channel in stock.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion