Supply Chain · Retail

The problem with size sets

Mohit Saini · 15 Aug 2022 · 4 min read

The problem with size sets

Anyone who has shopped for clothes or shoes knows the moment. You find a design you like, ask for your size, and the salesperson comes back empty-handed. They try to steer you to a different design. Sometimes you agree. Often you walk out.

At the end of the season, the same shop is left with racks of odd sizes, mostly the very small and very large ones, that end up in the sale.

Shortages and surpluses of the same design, at the same time. Why?

What a size set is

In fashion, every design is made in a range of sizes: S, M, L, XL, or 28, 30, 32, 34 and so on. Since people come in different sizes in different numbers, companies don’t make equal quantities of each. Instead, they use a size set (also called a ratio pack), designed to mirror the population. A typical set might be:

Size XS S M L XL XXL
Pieces 1 2 3 3 2 1

Factories produce in multiples of this set. Shops buy in multiples of this set. Logistics move whole sets.

It sounds scientific. But two things go wrong.

Problem 1: one shop is not the population

The size distribution of a whole country may follow a neat curve. The customers walking into one shop, for one design, on any given week, do not. A few customers of the same size may arrive one after another and sell out that size, while the others sit untouched. Different designs also appeal to different body types and age groups, so each design may sell in its own size pattern.

A small sample doesn’t look like the population. Expecting each shop’s sales of each design to match the national size curve is a statistical mistake.

Problem 2: you can only buy the whole set

Now combine this with the rule that shops can only buy full size sets.

A design is selling well, but sizes M and L are sold out. The retailer would love to reorder. But reordering means a full set, including more XS and XXL that haven’t sold yet. Fear of getting stuck with odd sizes stops him from reordering a winning design. The sale is lost.

Take the set above: 12 pieces, in the ratio 1-2-3-3-2-1. A shop receives one set of a new design. In two weeks it sells all 3 M and all 3 L, one S, and nothing else. Customers are still asking for M and L.

To get 3 more M and 3 more L, the shop must order a full set again: another 12 pieces, including another XS, two more S, two more XL and another XXL, when it already holds 1 XS, 1 S, 2 XL and 1 XXL that haven’t sold. Six of the twelve pieces it needs; six it doesn’t. Most retailers look at that and decide not to reorder. Some customers who wanted an M walk out, and the design that was selling best is quietly allowed to run out.

At the end of the season, the shop is left with odd sizes of good designs and odd designs in every size. Discounts and markdowns follow.

Why the industry holds on to sets

If size sets cause so much damage, why do they persist? Mostly because of production efficiency.

In weaving, garment making and shoe making, changing from one design to another takes a significant set-up. Changing sizes within a design usually doesn’t. So it seems efficient to make all sizes of a design in one go, in fixed proportions.

But look at the result: capacity is spent making sizes that end up in the sale, while sizes that customers want aren’t made. Is that really efficient? Producing by design-and-size may add some set-ups, but it stops capacity being wasted on stock nobody buys.

The solution is simple

  1. The first supply of a new design to a shop can be one of each relevant size, or a basic set, to give every size a chance.
  2. Every supply after that is strictly according to consumption, size by size. Whatever sold is replaced. Whatever didn’t sell is not.
  3. Replenishment from the warehouse and from production is planned at size level, not set level.

This keeps every size of a selling design available, so lost sales disappear, while sizes that aren’t selling don’t pile up.

It does require changes in ERP settings, in production and shipping policies, and in how buyers think about orders. But companies that make the shift typically see stock-outs fall dramatically, sales rise, and fewer odd sizes left for the end-of-season sale.

The market decides the size set, and it decides a different one for every design. Let it.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion