Sales · Supply Chain

Fighting fake products with availability

Mohit Saini · 12 Jan 2026 · 4 min read

Fighting fake products with availability

Take your car or motorbike to a neighbourhood garage for a repair, and the mechanic will probably replace a part or two. A filter, brake pads, a bulb, a belt. Are you sure they were genuine?

Counterfeit products are a large and growing problem, from auto parts to medicines, cosmetics, electrical goods and packaged foods. Fakes hurt the customer (sometimes dangerously, as with brake parts or medicines), cost the genuine brand its sales and reputation, and cost governments tax revenue.

Brands fight back hard:

  • raids and legal action with the police and enforcement agencies,
  • awareness campaigns, especially in small towns and villages,
  • smaller, cheaper packs to remove the price incentive,
  • better packaging, special labels, holograms and codes that are hard to copy.

Yet in many categories, fakes keep growing. And there is an interesting pattern: the measures seem to work reasonably well in big-city retail, while small towns and semi-urban markets remain flooded. Categories where brands reach most retailers directly tend to have fewer fakes than categories where brands reach only a fraction of the market.

That points to an uncomfortable explanation: counterfeiters thrive where genuine brands don’t reach.

How the gap opens

Most of the population in many countries lives outside the big cities. But companies build their distribution around the cities, because decisions are made on “cost to serve”. Small retailers in small towns are written off as not economical to serve directly. Instead, companies sell in bulk to wholesalers and hope the product finds its way to those markets.

But wholesalers are passive sellers. They sell to whoever comes to them.

The small retailer’s problem

Look at it from the small retailer’s side. To restock genuine products, he has to:

  • close his shop and travel to the wholesaler in the nearest town, losing sales while he is away;
  • pay for transport, so he goes as rarely as possible;
  • buy in large lots, for cash, which his limited capital can’t stretch to many items;
  • live with slow items he can’t return.

So he ends up with a narrow range, bought in bulk, infrequently, with his money locked up. The further he is from the wholesaler, the worse it gets.

Who solves his problem

Now an agent turns up at his shop, every week or two. This agent:

  • delivers to his door, so he doesn’t close the shop or pay for transport,
  • sells in small quantities, so his money turns faster,
  • often gives credit,
  • and always has something to offer when a popular brand runs out: a look-alike.

The agent sells counterfeits. But from the retailer’s point of view, he offers better service and a better return on investment than the genuine brand does. Soon the retailer rarely visits the wholesaler. His customers accept the fakes, out of ignorance or because there is nothing else on the shelf. Over time, some fake brands even build a following.

Counterfeiters don’t just copy the product. They copy the service the genuine brand failed to provide.

Do the retailer’s sums. A village parts shop sells about ₹30,000 a month of a genuine brand’s filters and bulbs, at a 20% margin: ₹6,000. To restock, the owner shuts the shop one day a month to visit the town wholesaler, spends ₹500 on the trip, loses perhaps ₹1,500 of sales that day, and buys two months’ worth in cash: ₹50,000 locked up. The look-alike agent, by contrast, comes to his door every week, sells him a week’s need on credit, and leaves him a similar or better margin. The shopkeeper’s money turns four or five times faster with the fake, with no lost day and no trip. On those terms, the genuine brand loses before the customer has even walked in.

Reach is the necessary condition

This is why raids and awareness alone can’t win. They are important, but as long as small retailers aren’t served directly by the genuine brand, the counterfeiter’s network fills the gap. The genuine brand must out-serve the counterfeiter:

  • Direct distribution through distributors with a defined territory, whose salespeople visit every retailer on a regular schedule.
  • Small, frequent supplies according to what each shop sells, so the retailer’s money turns faster with the genuine brand than with the fake.
  • Full range availability, so the retailer never needs a look-alike to fill a gap.

A side benefit: when the brand’s own people visit every shop regularly, they also see where fakes are being sold. Underreporting of counterfeits is one of the biggest obstacles to tackling them.

“But serving small shops costs too much”

Companies often know their dependence on wholesalers is unhealthy, but believe closing the gap is too expensive. They rarely count what the wholesaler model already costs:

  • The brand competes with itself. Wholesalers sell into distributors’ territories at deep discounts. Distributors’ margins shrink, and they can no longer afford regular visits to retailers. Sales fall further.
  • Erratic orders create excess stock. Occasional bulk orders from small retailers encourage wholesalers to buy even more. When those retailers don’t return, the wholesaler is stuck, his credit with the company freezes, and future sales suffer.

Add these up, even before counting the sales lost to fakes, and direct distribution often turns out cheaper than the status quo.

The transition is uncomfortable. Many companies effectively price like wholesalers themselves, with lower prices for bulk buyers, which keeps wholesalers in business. Moving away from bulk selling can mean a short-term dip in primary sales that top management finds hard to accept. But once direct distribution is in place and visits happen reliably, companies find they have both fewer fakes and more sales.

Related reading

Mohit Saini

Strategy, supply chain & sales transformation consultant. About · Book a discussion